Skip to content
Home » Mattresses » Best Mattresses That Come With a Lifetime Warranty (Top 5 Picks)

Best Mattresses That Come With a Lifetime Warranty (Top 5 Picks)

Lifetime warranties featured image

At times we are compensated for the links you click at no cost to you. Learn more about why you should trust our reviews and view our disclosure page.

Mattresses are one of the most expensive purchases you can make, and it’s important that you choose a brand with a great warranty to help protect it in the event of a manufacturing defect. The following mattress brands come with lifetime warranties. The best mattress with a lifetime warranty is Puffy.

Best lifetime warranty mattresses in 2022

  1. Puffy – Editor’s choice – Overall best
  2. Idle Plush – Best soft mattress
  3. Dreamcloud – Best hybrid mattress
  4. Layla Memory Foam Mattress – Best memory foam mattress
  5. The Winkbed – Best mattress for pain relief

#1. Puffy

Check Current Price | Editor’s Choice | Review

Puffy mattress with red background
Puffy mattress

Puffy pros

  • Low motion transfer
  • Great for back and side sleepers
  • Good edge support
  • Free delivery
  • 101-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty

Puffy cons

  • Not quite as bouncy as other brands
  • Not great for heavyweight sleepers over 230 pounds

Our experience with Puffy

Puffy is one of my all-time favorite memory foam mattresses. Based on our testing, we rate Puffy as being a medium-firm mattress that is great for all sleeping positions.

Since it’s made entirely out of memory foam and doesn’t contain any innerspring coils, Puffy mattress isn’t a great choice for heavyweight sleepers who weigh more than 230 pounds. The lack of coils means that it won’t provide quite as much support as an innerspring mattress or hybrid mattress. When we tried it out, we determined that it is a great option for people who are average weight or lower.

Puffy mattress lifetime warranty

Puffy mattress comes with a lifetime warranty with your mattress purchase. Puffy will replace your mattress with a brand new one free of charge for as long as you own it if you find a valid manufacturing defect.

In order to quality for lifetime warranty coverage:
  • You must use your mattress on an appropriate sized and suitable bed frame or base.
  • You can not burn, abuse, misuse, or damage your mattress through improper use
Covered defects
  • Visible sagging or indentation great than 1.5″ that isn’t a result of improper use or an improper bed base, frame, or foundation
  • Manufacturing flaws in the cover zipper not including zipper breakage caused by improper or overuse of the zipper
  • Physical flaws in the construction of the cover including fabric tearing or stitch unraveling not caused by improper usage
Defects that are *not* covered by the Puffy mattress warranty
  • Normal wear and tear
  • Improper use
  • Slight cosmetic flaws or other minor imperfections
  • Stains, tears, burns, or discoloration that occur over time or are caused by you
  • Sagging, indents, or body indentations that are less than 1.5″ deep
  • Personal preferences in regards to mattress firmness, softness, or other attributes
  • Used, gifted, or resold mattress (only applies to the original owner)
  • Mattresses purchased from an unauthorized distributor
  • Physical damage to the mattress caused by you
  • Allergies or other sensitivities to the mattress components
  • Damage caused by children, rodents, or animals
  • Naturally-occurring smells from the memory foam, cotton, or other mattress materials
How to make a warranty claim

If you find a covered defect in your Puffy mattress, contact customer service and have the following information handy:

  1. Your first and last name
  2. Order number
  3. Brief description of the defect
  4. A photo or video showing the defect

Puffy will look into your claim and respond within seven business days with a decision.

Buy: Puffy Mattress

#2. Idle Plush

Check Current Price | Best Soft Mattress | 30% Off Coupon: SLEEPLINE | Review

Idle Sleep mattress with green background
Idle Gel Plush mattress

Idle pros

  • Plush, cradled-in feel
  • 4 cooling tech layers
  • Machine-washable cover
  • 548-night sleep trial

Idle cons

  • May be too plush and soft for some
  • Available in only one firmness level
  • Too thick for some

Save 30% with coupon code “SLEEPLINE”

Our experience with Idle Sleep

Idle Plush is a medium-soft gel memory foam mattress that comes with four layers of cooling gel. When I tried the Idle Plush mattress, I found that it did a great job of keeping me cool throughout the night and that it provided an incredibly soft feel. We rate this memory foam mattress as being medium-soft, which means that it’s great for people who want a cradled-in feel.

The downside to the Idle Plush mattress is that it is only available in one firmness level. If you prefer a firmer mattress, we recommend looking elsewhere.

Idle Sleep mattress warranty

Idle Plush mattress comes with a limited lifetime warranty that is valid for the original purchaser of the mattress. The mattress company will replace your mattress free of charge for as long as you own it if you make a valid warranty claim.

How to qualify for the Idle Sleep mattress warranty
  • You must be the original purchaser of the mattress
  • You must retain your proof of purchase
Covered defects
  • Deterioration causing a visible indent of greater than 1.75″ for the Idle and Idle Plush or 1.5″ for the Idle Hybrid and Idle Latex Hybrid mattress models that is not caused by using an improper or unsupportive bed base
  • Physical flaws that causes the memory foam material to split or crack despite normal usage and proper handling
  • Defects in the mattress cover assembly
  • Any defect in the springs or other mattress components
What isn’t covered?
  • Comfort preferences
  • Physical damage or abuse including tears, burns, cuts, stains, or liquid damage
  • Non-defective materials will not be replaced
  • Mattresses purchased from non-authorized retailers
  • Mattresses purchased as-is, used, preconditioned, reconditioned, previously-owned, returned, or any other wording indicating that it’s not a new mattress
  • Damage caused by fires, natural disasters, or robbery
How to make a warranty claim

To make a claim under Idle Sleep’s lifetime limited warranty, contact their customer service team. They will respond with more information about what they need to process your mattress warranty claim.

Buy: Idle Plush

#3. Dreamcloud

Check Current Price | Best Hybrid Mattress | Review

Dreamcloud mattress purple background
Dreamcloud mattress

Dreamcloud pros

  • Cooling mattress
  • Luxurious feel
  • Great pressure relief

Dreamcloud cons

  • Not the best for side sleepers
  • Available in only one firmness level
  • Too firm for lightweight people

Our experience with Dreamcloud

Dreamcloud is a popular hybrid mattress that combines memory foam comfort layers with an innerspring support core. If you want the benefits of memory foam mattresses combined with innerspring mattresses, then hybrids are the way to go.

When I tested out Dreamcloud, I noticed that it provides a great cooling effect. Sleeping on Dreamcloud feels incredibly luxurious and just as high-quality as brands that sell for at much higher price points. I also found that it provides great pressure relief compared to other mattress brands.

We found that it’s not the best option for side sleepers. People who sleep in the side sleeping position might want to look elsewhere for a softer mattress. It’s also a little bit too firm for lightweight sleepers, but people who are average weight or above should find this to be a comfortable mattress.

Dreamcloud mattress warranty

For the first ten years of your lifetime warranty, Dreamcloud will replace your mattress with a brand new mattress at no cost to you. After ten years, Dreamcloud with either repair, re-cover, or replace your defective mattress at their discretion. They will waive all transportation costs if they find that a covered defect exists.

How to qualify for the Dreamcloud lifetime warranty
  • You must be the original purchaser of the mattress
  • You must retain a copy of your receipt as proof of purchase
What is covered?
  • Visible indentation greater than 1.5″ that isn’t caused by using an improper bed base or foundation
  • Physical flaws that cause the memory foam to split, crack, or show degradation with normal usage and proper handling
  • Manufacturing defects in the assembly of the mattress cover
What isn’t covered?
  • Any damage caused by misuse, neglect, accident, or by violating instructions
  • Normal increase in the softness of the memory foam that does not affect the pressure-relieving properties of the mattress
  • Comfort preferences
  • Defects caused by cuts, burns, liquid damage, tears, or stains
  • Mattresses that were purchased as used, reconditioned, returned, previously-owned or similar wording indicating that it is not a new mattress
How to make a claim

In order to make a claim on your lifetime warranty, you’ll need to contact Dreamcloud’s customer service and show proof of purchase. The mattress company will require you to return your defective mattress free of charge in the first ten years. In years 10+, you’ll have to pay a $50 shipping fee that will be waived if the company finds a covered defect. Dreamcloud may request that you take a photo of the defect in lieu of returning your mattress.

Buy: Dreamcloud

#4. Layla Memory Foam Mattress

Check Current Price | Best Memory Foam Mattress | Review

Layla hybrid mattress
Layla mattress

Layla pros

  • Flippable
  • Antimicrobial
  • Great for stomach sleepers

Layla cons

  • Some off-gassing
  • Less support on the firm side compared to other firm mattress brands

Our experience with Layla

Layla is a unique mattress because it’s made out of a copper gel-infused memory foam that, in our experience, provides much more support in deep compression areas such as the hips and shoulders. This makes is a great memory foam mattress for back pain since it combines the benefits of a soft and firm mattress all-in-one.

We really liked the fact that you can flip it between a soft side and a firm side. If you aren’t sure which type of mattress you prefer or if you know that you like to switch between firm and soft, then Layla is a great choice. The one downside to Layla is that the firm side provides slightly less support when compared to the firm mattresses made by other mattress companies. I also noticed that there was some off-gassing when I first took my mattress out of the box, but it quickly dissipated.

Layla mattress warranty

Layla offers a lifetime warranty on their memory foam mattress only. If you decide to buy their hybrid mattress, then you’ll only get a 10-year warranty.

The lifetime warranty on the Layla memory foam mattress certifies that your purchase will be free of defects in material and workmanship that can compromise sleep quality for the life of the mattress.

How to qualify for the Layla lifetime warranty
  • You must be the original purchaser of the memory foam mattress
  • The mattress must be used properly and supported on a firm, rigid, and smooth surface such as a box spring or slatted bed frames
What is covered?
  • Seams coming apart
  • Visible permanent compression of the mattress surface greater than 1″
What isn’t covered?
  • Faults in cosmetic appearance including wrinkling
  • Cosmetic changes occurring naturally over time, including natural blemishes
  • Soiled, dampened, burned, stained, or abused memory foam mattresses
  • Mattress dimension discrepancies up to 1″
  • Mold or vermin infestation due to improper or unsanitary care of the mattress
How to make a claim

If you have a problem with your new mattress, contact Layla’s customer service team. Layla will repair or replace the defective component of the mattress. They will decide whether to replace the specific component or the entire mattress depending on the defect.

Layla may charge a $50 shipping fee when replacing your mattress that they may decide to waive at their discretion.

Buy: Layla Memory Foam Mattress

#5. The Winkbed

Check Current Price | Best Mattress for Pain Relief | $300 Off Coupon: SLEEP300

Winkbed innerspring mattress
Winkbed mattress

Winkbed pros

  • Excellent pain relief
  • Eases muscle tension
  • Great motion isolation

Winkbed cons

  • Some customers have had difficulties with returns

Our experience with Winkbed

Winkbed is one of my favorite hybrid mattresses. The quilted EuroTop foam is infused with cooling and stabilizing gel, which in our experience, provided a great cooling effect and helped the mattress feel more supportive. The support system gives you benefits of an innerspring mattress and contains multi-zoned individually-wrapped coils that help alleviate pressure.

Winkbed is available in three different firmness levels: softer, luxury firm, and firmer. They also have a “plus” option for heavyweight sleepers. I personally recommend the firmer mattress, but your personal preferences will determine the best option for you.

Winkbed mattress warranty

Winkbed’s lifetime limited warranty is valid for the entire lifespan of your mattress if you’re the original purchaser. Like other lifetime warranties, it protects you from defects in material and workmanship for as long as you own the mattress.

How to qualify for the Winkbed lifetime warranty
  • You must prove that you used a proper foundation, adjustable bed base, or frame
  • You must show proof of original purchase
What is covered?
  • Deterioration causing the mattress to have a visible indentation greater than 1.5″ that was not caused by using an improper foundation or bed base
  • Any physical flaw in the mattress caused by a manufacturing defect that causes the memory foam layers or springs to split, degrade, or crack with normal usage
What is not covered?
  • Damage caused by misuse, neglect, accident, or violation of instructions
  • Normal increases in the softness of the memory foam that doesn’t affect the pressure-relieving qualities of the mattress
  • Comfort preferences
  • Defects caused by physical abuse or damage to the structure or cover material including burns, cuts, stains, liquid damage, or tears
  • Mattresses sold as-is, preconditioned, reconditioned, used, returned, or previously-owned; or any similar wording indicating that it’s not a new mattress
How to make a claim

Contact the Winkbed customer service team for further information on how to make a claim on your mattress warranty.

Buy: The Winkbed

How do I buy a mattress with a good warranty?

Federal law stipulates that you must have the opportunity to read a warranty before you buy a product. That’s why all mattress companies have a warranty page on their website that lists the terms and exclusions. Make sure you read through the mattress warranties of all the different brands you’re considering before you make your purchase so you don’t encounter any surprises when you have to make a claim.

Frequently asked questions

How do mattress warranties work?

There are two different types of mattress warranties: implied warranties and written warranties.

All 50 states have passed laws that regulated implied warranties, which ensure that you have legal recourse if the mattress you buy doesn’t come with a written warranty. The main exceptions to this type of warranty are mattresses that are sold ‘as-is’ and mattresses sold by companies that specifically state in writing that they don’t offer a warranty.

Some states prohibit ‘as-is’ sales. Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, Maryland, and Mississippi all prohibit ‘as-is’ sales.

Implied warranty of merchantability means that the product is guaranteed to do what it’s supposed to do. An implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose means that that product is suitable for a particular use.

Virtually all mattress companies offer a written warranty that offers you specific protections. You’ll need to read the warranty information that the company lists on its website for specifics; but most written mattress warranties protect you against indentations and defects in materials and workmanship for a specified length of time.

The mattress companies on this list all offer a lifetime warranty length, but other mattress brands limit their warranties to a shorter length of time. Common warranty lengths offered by reputable mattress manufacturers include 20 years (e.g. Amerisleep), 15 years (e.g. Saatva), and variable depending on model (e.g. Serta and Beautyrest).

What do mattress warranties cover?

Most mattress warranties cover the following defects:

  1. Sagging – Sagging or sinking that exceeds a specified depth – usually 1.5″ or 1.75″ – that hasn’t been caused by using improper foundations
  2. Zippers and seams – Zippers that are broken or nonfunctional, seams that come undone, and handles that don’t stay attached are generally covered
  3. Coils – Bent or broken coils are covered if you buy an innerspring mattress. If the coils are poking through the fabric, that is also generally covered by reputable mattress manufacturers
  4. Irregular lumps – If lumps are caused by a manufacturing defect in the memory foam, latex foam, or polyurethane foam; then you are generally covered.

What don’t mattress warranties cover?

Most mattress warranties won’t cover the following:

  1. Minor sagging – If you experience sagging that doesn’t exceed the specified threshold, then your limited warranty doesn’t apply
  2. Damage caused by neglect – The mattress manufacturer will not repair or replace your mattress if you misuse or improperly care for it
  3. Normal wear and tear – Minor damage caused by repeated use over time is not covered
  4. Comfort preferences – You can’t get a replacement mattress if you decide that your mattress isn’t comfortable enough. Changes in preference regarding mattress firmness, sleeping position, pressure relief, mattress thickness, and more are not covered

How we rate mattresses

We rate mattresses using the following criteria:

  1. Comfort
  2. Structural integrity and durability
  3. Firmness and support

Learn more about our mattress rating process and methodology here.

Related product reviews:

Psst… the sleep review industry is full of liars, sharks, and thieves. It’s a modern-day version of getting ripped off at your local mattress store. So, why should you trust us?