Best mattress toppers according to Reddit – hands-on performance tests

At times we are compensated for the links you click at no cost to you. Learn more about why you should trust our reviews and view our disclosure page.

---

Reddit reviews tend to be no holds barred and sometimes even downright brutal. From electronic gadgets to the best taco trucks to mattresses, Reddit has an opinion on just about everything. We have put together a list of the best mattress toppers, according to the ‘first page of the internet’. Our Editor’s Choice is the Helix Premium Mattress Topper with GlacioTex.

---

---

Best Mattress Toppers According to Reddit and Performance Test Results

---

#1. Helix Premium Mattress Topper with GlacioTex

Pros

• Comes in two firmness levels
• Cooling
• Greenguard Gold-certified
• Good for all sleeper types

Cons

• Slight off-gassing
• May be too plush for heavier-set sleepers

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

Why it’s the best mattress topper according to Reddit

Not a lot of mattress toppers contain coils (or in the case of the Helix Premium Mattress Topper, micro-coils) but those that do feel like mini mattresses that elevate your actual mattress.

Take the Helix Premium Mattress Topper for instance.

The most talked about mattress topper on Reddit, the Helix Premium Mattress Topper is the only topper that is constructed just like an actual hybrid mattress.

Containing multiple layers of foam as well as a micro-coil unit, the Helix Premium Mattress Topper provides either added plushness or firmness depending on the firmness level that you choose and prefer.

But the micro-coils also provide an added layer of support and who does not want that?

Specs at a glance

Helix Premium Mattress Topper With GlacioTex Performance

The Helix Premium Mattress Topper comes in two different firmness levels: luxury plush and luxury firm.

The luxury plush option is best for side sleepers while the luxury firm option is best for back and stomach sleepers.

We rate the Helix Premium Mattress Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

Not only does this mattress provide pressure relief and plushness but it also helps provide extra support.

We rate the Helix Premium Mattress Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Although the topper does contain two layers of manmade foam (which would normally make you sleep hot); Helix’s proprietary GlacioTex cooling cover and micro-coils provide breathability, cooling and air flow. This topper did very well in my cooling test.

We rate the Helix Premium Mattress Topper a 7.5 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

Most mattress toppers don’t contribute much to motion transfer but because this one contains a coil unit, you might experience some added movement especially if you have a mattress that already has high motion transfer.

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

---

#2. Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper

Pros

• Natural and all-organic
• Plush and pressure relieving
• Cooling and hypoallergenic
• Greenguard Gold-certified

Cons

• May be too soft for heavier-set sleepers
• Slight, earthy smell

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

Why it’s one of the best

If natural and all-organic is what you’re after, then you can’t get any better than the Birch Plush Organic mattress topper which is Reddit’s top pick for a natural topper.

Made from natural and organic materials such as latex foam and organic cotton, the Birch Plush Organic mattress topper is also naturally cooling and hypoallergenic (making it a good choice for hot sleepers).

Just like natural and organic mattresses, the Birch Natural Organic feels responsive rather than compressing, but it still has a plush feel.

Specs at a glance

Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper Performance Test Results

The Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper has medium-soft firmness level which can help add plushness and responsiveness to your bed especially if you have a firmer mattress.

Most sleeper types will find that they can sleep comfortably on the Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper.

We rate the Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The topper performed excellently during our comfort and pressure relief tests. Aside from pressure relief, it also provides responsive support.

We rate the Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

As I’ve mentioned, pure latex is naturally cooling and the latex foam layer does not retain any heat whatsoever, making it good for those who sleep hot.

We rate the Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper an 9 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

With only 2 inches thickness, you really won’t be feeling anything in terms of cross-mattress movement.

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

---

#3. Nolah Mattress Topper

Pros

• Pressure-relieving
• Offers deep contouring
• Good for chronic pain
• Good for all sleeper types

Cons

• Slight off-gassing
• Slightly heat-retentive

$50 off coupon code: SLEEPLINE50

Why it’s one of the best

The Nolah Mattress Topper is made from Airfoam, the same type of foam that’s in the Nolah Evolution which is Nolah’s most popular mattress offering.

The best thing I (and Redditors) liked about the Nolah Mattress Topper is that it feels and sleeps just like a memory foam mattress, which means it cradles every contour of your body while providing pressure point relief.

This also means that the Nolah Mattress Topper is amazing for those who suffer from back pain.

Specs at a glance

Nolah Mattress Topper Performance Test Results

You get to choose between two different firmness levels: Plush and Luxury Firm. 

The plush version is best for side sleepers. The luxury firm version is good for all other sleeper types including stomach and back sleepers.

We rate the Nolah Mattress Topper an 9.5 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

You get exactly the same compression and pressure relief as you would with a classic memory foam mattress. When I tested it out on a firm mattress, it did an excellent job of reducing the aches and pains I felt on key pressure point areas (shoulders, hips, etc.).

We rate the Nolah Mattress Topper a 6.5 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Unfortunately, I found it to be somewhat heat-retentive so I don’t recommend it for those who sleep extremely hot.

We rate the Nolah Mattress Topper an 7.5 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

For a mattress topper that’s only 2 inches, it doesn’t do much in the way of absorbing movement.

$50 off coupon code: SLEEPLINE50

---

#4. Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper

Pros

• Comes in three different firmness options
• Good for heavier-set sleepers
• Provides responsive support
• Cooling

Cons

• Not as compressing as memory foam
• Slight earthy smell

25% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE25

Why it’s one of the best

A lot of Redditors are huge fans of the Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper and with good reason – thicker than most toppers, the Brooklyn Bedding Latex Topper adds not only loft but more responsive support as well.

Another thing of note with the Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper is that it is made from premium and organic Talalay latex which is not only naturally cooling but is hypoallergenic as well.

You also get to choose between three different firmness options which means there’s something for everyone.

Specs at a glance

Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper Performance Test Results

There are 3 different firmness options to choose from with the Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper: soft, medium, and firm. 

Just like traditional mattress firmness levels, the soft version is best for side sleepers. The medium version is an ‘all-rounder’ that’s good for all sleeper types. The firm version is best for those who sleep on their backs and stomachs.

We rate the Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper an 8 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

Although it won’t be able to provide you with that deep compression that only memory foam can bring, it still provides enough comfort and responsive support (especially for those who suffer from joint pain).

We rate the Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

As I have mentioned, organic latex is naturally cooling and temperature-regulating and won’t retain any heat; making this topper a good choice for hot sleepers.

We rate the Brooklyn Bedding 3” Latex Topper a 7.5 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

Natural latex is bouncier than manmade foam which can cause a little bit of motion transfer. Those who share a bed with a partner should manage their expectations accordingly.

25% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE25

---

#5. Bear Pro Topper

Pros

• Offers deep compression
• Pressure-relieving
• Good for those with chronic pain
• Best for side sleepers

Cons

• Too soft for back and stomach sleepers
• Can be heat-retentive

35% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE35

Why it’s one of the best

Made especially for side sleepers who need that extra something something, the Bear Pro Topper is made up of Bear’s very own proprietary memory foam that cradles all joints.

My favorite thing about the Bear Pro Topper is that sleeping on it feels like you’re sleeping on a cloud.

The majority of Reddit reviewers agree with me on this: I woke up pain-free when I slept on the Bear Pro Topper which is why I definitely recommend it to those who are living with chronic pain.

There is a caveat though to all that plush and pain-relieving softness: the Bear Pro Topper is just too soft for those who sleep on their backs and stomachs.

Specs at a glance

Bear Pro Topper Performance Test Results

The Bear Pro Topper has a soft firmness level.

A soft mattress topper essentially makes your mattress plusher which is only beneficial for those who sleep on their sides as well as those who suffer from chronic pain.

We rate the Bear Pro Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

There’s no denying that memory foam is top dog when it comes to pressure point relief. This topper essentially aced my comfort and pressure relief tests.

We rate the Bear Pro Topper a 6.5 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Even though the memory foam layer of the is copper-infused (copper is a good heat conductor), I still found the mattress topper to be a bit too heat-retentive.

We rate the Bear Pro Topper a 10 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

The thick memory foam layer does a very good job of absorbing cross-mattress movement, which could increase your bed’s overall motion-isolating capabilities.

35% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE35

---

#6. Moon Pod Cloud Mattress Topper

Pros

• Plush and pressure relieving
• Feels like a down pillow
• Helps with spinal alignment
• Best for side sleepers

Cons

• Not suitable for back and stomach sleepers
• Heat-retentive

10% off coupon code: MOONSLEEPLINE

Why it’s one of the best

From the same creators of the viral beanbag chair that dominated not only TikTok but Reddit as well last year, the Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper is definitely one for the list.

Containing memory foam clusters that are surrounded by thousands of down alternative microfibers, the Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper actually feels like you are sleeping on a giant down-filled pillow.

This is especially beneficial for those who suffer from hip pain as well as those who sleep only on their sides.

In the same vein though, the Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper will barely give you any lumbar support, so those who sleep on their backs and stomachs should look at other options on this list.

Specs at a glance

Moon Pod Cloud Mattress Topper Performance Test Results

The Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper has a plush, down-like feel that’s best for side sleepers as well as those who suffer from chronic pain.

Back and stomach sleepers would benefit more from a mattress topper that is firmer than the Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper.

We rate the Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper a 10 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

Sleeping on this topper feels just like sleeping on a bed-sized down-filled pillow which definitely gets a 10 out of 10 in my book.

We rate the Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper a 6 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Unfortunately, the memory foam clusters retain a significant amount of heat which traps it in and makes you sleep warm.

We rate the Moon Pod Cloud mattress topper an 9 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

I found that the topper absorbed virtually all movement when I tried it out with a partner, making it a good choice for couples.

>> View full Moon Pod Mattress Topper review for more details

10% off coupon code: MOONSLEEPLINE

---

#7. Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper

Pros

• Provides targeted comfort
• Pressure-relieving
• Suitable for heavier-set people
• Cooling

Cons

• Slight off-gassing
• May be too soft for stomach sleepers

Why it’s one of the best

The Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper not only provides targeted comfort for the entire body but is made with a swirls-and-grooves pattern that allows for continuous air flow. 

Another thing I liked a lot about this topper is that it’s made from Ghostbed’s very own memory foam alternative, which didn’t retain any heat at all during my cooling tests.

Specs at a glance

Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper Performance

The Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper has a medium-soft feel that’s good for most sleeper types. However, it may feel too soft for some stomach sleepers.

We rate the Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

Plush and pressure relieving, it feels and sleeps just like an elevated memory foam mattress that also provides zoned and targeted support.

We rate the Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper an 8.5 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

This mattress topper is infused with cooling gel beads and also features an open-celled construction which helps it sleep cool.

We rate the Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper a 10 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

With its thicker construction, it performed amazingly well in our motion isolation tests.

>> View full Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper review for more details

---

#8. Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Pros

• Comes in multiple sizes
• Cooling
• Plush and luxurious feel
• Treated with Guardin

Cons

• Can be pricey
• Comes with only one-year warranty

Why it’s one of the best

Sleeping on the Saatva Graphie Memory Foam Topper feels comfortable due to the plush feel and yet, you still feel as though your joints are well-supported and not like you’re sinking into the bed.

Infused with graphite – which is a good heat conductor, the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Topper sleeps extremely cool, which is the number one reason why Reddit loves it.

Another thing that stands out for me is that just like with the Saatva Classic mattress, this topper is infused with Guardin – a plant-based antimicrobial treatment that helps keep the nasties away.

Specs at a glance

Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper Performance Test Results

The Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper has a medium-soft to medium feel that’s good for all sleeper types.

We rate the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Topper a 10 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

I noticed that the topper gives more of a cradling feel, so you feel like you’re sleeping ‘in’ your mattress rather than ‘on’ it. I’m personally a fan of that, which is why I gave it perfect marks in my comfort and pressure relief tests.

We rate the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

The foam didn’t retain any measurable amount of heat at all. It’s not quite as cool as a latex topper would be, but any heat retention won’t be noticeable at all to the average sleeper.

We rate the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Topper an 8 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

I did not feel any motion transfer at all when I tried it out with a partner.

---

#9. Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper

Pros

• Comes in different thicknesses
• Budget-friendly
• Zoned comfort
• Good for all sleeper types

Cons

• Does not come with a cover
• Slight off-gassing

12% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE12

Why it’s one of the best

Aside from being very affordable and looking very cute, the Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper holds its own when it comes to performance.

Featuring a classic egg crate design, the Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper provides zoned and targeted comfort just where you need it.

The same egg crate construction also allows for greater airflow for added cooling and freshness.

I also like that Egohome gives us the option to choose between different thicknesses which is something not a lot of mattress topper brands do.

Specs at a glance

Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper Performance Test Results

The Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper has a true medium feel that’s good for all sleeper types.

It can also support heavier-set people.

We rate the Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper a 9 out 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

Egohome’s Aerofusion foam feels and acts just like traditional memory foam so you get both pressure point relief as well as targeted comfort. Sleeping on this mattress topper gives me a bit of a cradling feeling.

We rate the Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper a 7 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

I did experience a small amount of heat retention but I would have to say it isn’t the worst I have tried.

We rate the Egohome Egg Crate Lavender Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

There was very little measurable motion transfer during the performance tests I ran it through in the Sleepline Testing Studio. If your partner tosses and turns, you won’t feel it.

12% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE12

---

#10. Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper

Pros

• All-natural
• Cooling and breathable
• Machine-washable
• Good for all sleeper types

Cons

• Not as compressing as manmade foam
• Not as plush as I would have liked

Free mattress protector coupon: Sleepline

Why it’s one of the best

Natural and organic are two words not only people on Reddit seem to love but people everywhere too. The Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper does not contain any manmade foam but instead contains natural cotton filling that suits a greener lifestyle.

I like the Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper because even if it does not contain any foam layers, it still gives structure to a softer bed and yet also gives softness to a firmer bed. It just magically works both ways.

The Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper is fiberglass-free and because it is filled with cotton, it is cooling and breathable making it good for hot sleepers.

Specs at a glance

Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper Performance Test Results

Although Sweet Zzz has not explicitly mentioned the firmness level of their Cotton Topper, I found it to be a true medium which is good for all sleeper types.

We rate the Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper an 8 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

While I found the material to be not as compressing as traditional memory foam, it still provided me with enough comfort and pressure relief when I tried it out.

We rate the Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper a 9 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Breathable and cooling, there is no heat retention at all. It’s a great choice for hot sleepers.

We rate the Sweet Zzz Cotton Topper a 10 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

I did not experience any motion transfer whatsoever when I tried the topper with a partner.

Free mattress protector coupon: Sleepline

---

How we chose these mattress toppers

• Materials – While most mattress toppers are composed of a single material such as memory foam or polyfoam, there’s also what we call a hybrid mattress topper. This type of topper contains two or more layers that are made of different materials (some even include a coil unit). Although choosing the right material will ultimately depend on your preferences, we recommend getting a durable mattress topper that will last for at least 3 years.
• Price – Mattress toppers have a wide price range depending on the material used. Polyfoam mattress toppers are the most affordable, while memory foam and natural latex toppers tend to be more expensive. If you want something really luxurious, take a look at high-quality down toppers.
• Sleeping position – Your preferred sleeping position is a crucial factor when choosing a mattress topper. For side sleepers, the most important thing is pressure relief for their hips and shoulders. While, both back and stomach sleepers need adequate support for their spine and hips to stay in alignment.
• Firmness – Since side sleepers need pressure relief for their hips and shoulders, we recommend soft mattress toppers for extra cushioning. On the other hand, back and stomach sleepers are all about spinal alignment. They need a supportive topper that will not let their hips sink too much into the mattress. We have a list of the firmest mattress toppers for you to choose from.
• Cooling capabilities – If your current mattress sleeps hot, you can counteract this by getting a mattress topper with cooling properties. There are several different cooling options you can choose from such as gel memory foam or gel-infused foam, and natural latex toppers. These materials help dissipate body heat and promote airflow to keep you sleeping cool all night.
• Pressure relief – Most sleepers experience pressure buildup in some areas of their body, especially their shoulders, hips, and lower back. It’s important to get a mattress topper that distributes your body weight evenly to alleviate tension and relieve pressure. Check out our best mattress topper for pressure point relief for some great options.
• Thickness – Mattress toppers typically range from 1-4 inches thick. A thinner topper will only slightly tweak the feel of a mattress without affecting the support it provides. Whereas, a thicker topper will modify the firmness of a mattress to a greater extent and provide deeper pressure relief.

---

Conclusion

We all know that Reddit usually has an opinion on everything and I do mean EVERYTHING and that includes mattress toppers.

On this list you can find Reddit’s top mattress topper picks.

I also personally tested them out to make sure that they meet Sleepline’s strict quantitative standards. We simply don’t recommend anything without running it through a series of hands-on performance tests.

So I can vouch for the fact that any mattress topper on this list will be a good choice.

---

How we rate mattress toppers

We personally test and rate mattress toppers using the following strict quantitative criteria:

1. Comfort
2. Structural integrity and durability
3. Firmness and support
4. Cooling capabilities
5. Pressure relief
6. Edge support
7. Motion isolation

Learn more about our mattress rating process and methodology here. 

Psst… the sleep review industry is full of liars, sharks, and thieves. It’s a modern-day version of getting ripped off at your local mattress store. So, why should you trust us?