At times we are compensated for the links you click at no cost to you. Learn more about why you should trust our reviews and view our disclosure page.
Got a mattress that you hate the firmness level of yet it’s still in its prime? Try a mattress topper. Mattress toppers are slabs of foam made from either memory foam or latex that are placed on top of mattresses to alter the firmness level and make them more comfortable. Mattress toppers can also help extend a mattress’ life span. We have compiled a list of the best mattress toppers available today. Our Editor’s Choice is the myWooly Latex Topper.
Top 5 Picks: Best Mattress Toppers According to Consumer Reports
- myWooly Latex Topper – editor’s choice
- Lift by Amerisleep – best for chronic and back pain
- Saatva Mattress Topper – best organic mattress topper
- Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper – best for hot sleepers
- Puffy Mattress Topper – best for strict side sleepers
#1. myWooly Latex Topper
Check Current Price | Editor’s Choice
Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Thermo-regulating | Some people may be allergic to wool |
| Hypoallergenic | Needs regular fluffing up |
| Responsive |
If you are looking for a plusher sleeping experience while adding to your bed’s responsiveness, you shouldn’t look any further than the myWooly Latex Topper. Made from 100% latex and 100% Shropshire wool, this latex topper not only increases your mattress’ comfort level but keeps you sleeping at the optimum sleep temperature.
Wool toppers are naturally thermo-regulating. They can help you keep warm when you sleep cold and also help you sleep cooler when you sleep hot. This makes it an excellent choice for hot sleepers. Wool is also a natural flame retardant, so the myWooly Latex Topper also adds an extra layer of protection for your existing mattress.
The myWooly Latex mattress topper features a hand-tufted surface that makes your bed feel like it belongs in a 5-star hotel. Many mattress toppers are just thick slabs of foam with an even surface. Tufting adds an almost pillow top-like feel to your mattress. This is an excellent choice if you have a firm mattress and you want to soften it up a little.
Latex mattress toppers are naturally more responsive than memory foam toppers. An organic latex mattress topper like the myWooly Latex Topper offers pressure relief without the ‘stuck in the mud’ feel. If you are someone who often switches sleeping positions throughout the night and currently have a mattress that feels like it’s swallowing you whole, adding a more responsive mattress topper could be the key to a good night’s sleep. Latex is also naturally hypoallergenic and choosing a latex topper is better if you suffer constantly from allergies.
The top and bottom layers of the myWooly Latex Topper are made out of 100% Shropshire wool batting. Shropshire wool is from (you guessed it) Shropshire in the UK and is one of the best wool in the world. The middle fill layer is made up of a combination of 100% wooly puffs and 100% latex noodles. The entire topper comes encased in 100% organic cotton cover that helps wick heat and moisture away. It is also OEKO-TEX and Woolmark certified.
Because all of the materials in the myWooly Latex Topper are all-natural and organic, there might be a wooly, slightly earthy smell to it. We did not, however, experience any incidents of off-gassing upon unboxing the topper. If you are averse to the natural, earthy smell, airing out the topper before initial use could be beneficial. In fact, myWooly recommends regular sunning and airing out of the mattress topper in between uses to keep it in tiptop shape. Regular fluffing up of the topper is also recommended.
While all the materials in the myWooly Latex Topper is washable, myWooly advises against machine-washing due to the latex topper’s sheer size. Should any spills or accidents happen, you may spot clean with a soft brush and a mild detergent. We recommend always using a protective fitted sheet when using latex toppers.
The myWooly Topper measures 3 inches thick and features a 5-inch perimeter border tufting as well as 2 straps for the best mattress fit. It comes in 6 standard mattress sizes:
- Twin
- Twin XL
- Full
- Queen
- King
- California King
The myWooly Latex Topper comes with a 5 year warranty.
Buy: myWooly Latex Topper
#2. Lift by Amerisleep
Check Current Price | Best for Chronic & Back Pain | Review
Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Comes in 2 firmness options | Slight off-gassing |
| Responsive | May be too thin for some |
| Cooling |
If you want firmness options when it comes to mattress topper shopping, Amerisleep’s Lift mattress topper comes in both a soft and a firm. This makes it an excellent choice for all sleeper types.
Featuring the same proprietary tech as with Amerisleep’s well-loved mattresses, the Lift mattress topper is made with a memory foam alternative that provides contouring comfort without any sinking that is usually associated with regular memory foam. Each firmness option does feature slightly different proprietary tech.
- Comfort Lift – The Comfort Lift is Amerisleep’s soft mattress topper option. It features Amerisleep’s BioPur foam technology, which provides body contouring pressure relief without any of the sunk-in feel. This option is geared toward side sleepers and combination sleepers.
- Support Lift – Firmer and more supportive, the Support Lift features Amerisleep’s Affinity foam tech which is also found in their firmer mattresses. Still providing the same amount of pressure relief, the Support Lift firmness option allows sleepers to sleep on top of the bed rather than in it. This is best for strict back sleepers and stomach sleepers.
You do, however, have your own choices to make. If you are a strict back sleeper and feel that you’re mattress is a little too firm, it does not mean that you cannot choose the softer mattress topper option. And if you find your mattress to be too soft, you would want to opt for a firmer topper. Let’s not forget, the purpose of a mattress topper is to alter the feel of your existing mattress to balance everything out.
Both the BioPur and Affinity foam feature an open-cell tech that allows for more air circulation making it a good choice for those who tend to sleep hot. Other foam toppers – especially ones made from traditional memory foam – have a tendency to trap body heat and Amerisleep’s Lift mattress topper can help you sleep a little cooler.
Both the BioPur and Affinity foam also feature Amerisleep’s HIVE technology which can provide increased comfort, pressure relief and zoned support, just like their mattresses. This makes it a great choice for those who suffer from chronic pain or even back pain.
HIVE stands for Harnessing Intelligent Ventilation and Energy. This tech, which is exclusive to Amerisleep, provides targeted support and can help reduce pain-causing pressure points for up to 49%. There are 5 comfort zones in the Lift mattress topper, giving full support and comfort from head to toe.
While the right mattress topper can help last your old mattress last a little bit longer, mattresses that are way past their prime may not be salvageable no matter what mattress topper you use. If your mattress is sagging, lumpy or completely worn down, you might be better off shopping for a new mattress. A lumpy mattress cannot be saved.
The foam layer in the Amerisleep Lift mattress topper comes encased in a soft, removable mattress cover that is also machine washable. Amerisleep does advocate the use of a mattress protector even if you use a mattress topper. This helps keep both your mattress and the mattress topper clean, fresh and dry. Only the cover of the Lift mattress topper is washable, the foam layer is not.
As with their mattresses, the foam used in the mattress topper is CertiPUR-US certified. We did experience a slight new mattress smell when we unboxed the Lift mattress topper but this dissipated within a few days.
The Amerisleep Lift mattress topper measures 3 inches thick, which is the standard for most mattress toppers. It comes in 6 sizes:
- Twin
- Twin XL
- Full
- Queen
- King
- California King
Amerisleep offers a 5-year warranty for their mattress topper. The Lift mattress topper does not come with a sleep trial.
Buy: Lift by Amerisleep
#3. Saatva Mattress Topper
Check Current Price | Best Organic Mattress Topper
Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Organic and all natural | Can be too thin for some |
| Greenguard Gold certified | Can be too pricey |
| Comes in 3 options |
A ‘best mattress toppers’ list would not be complete without a Saatva mention. We all know that Saatva is one of the leading premium mattress brands in the country and their mattresses top a lot of “Best of” lists, including a few of our own.
Saatva’s mattress toppers work well with all types of mattresses, from innerspring mattresses to all-foam beds. Saatva offers three different foam types for their mattress topper, giving sleepers a wide range of options – from cooling to maximum pressure relief as well as something for memory foam fans.
- Graphite – In lieu of the more traditional and yet heat retaining memory foam, Saatva utilizes graphite-infused memory foam for this mattress topper option. Meant for true memory foam fans who also sleep hot, Saatva’s Graphite mattress topper draws heat away from the body and away from the mattress. Because it is made from memory foam, it offers that body contouring feel which provides extra pressure relief for those who need it. It does have that true memory foam feel, which means it has that ‘sink-in’ sensation. It has a medium firmness level, which makes it suitable for all sleeper types. The Graphite mattress topper is Saatva’s thickest topper, measuring 3 inches in thickness.
- Latex – For those who prefer a more responsive bed, Saatva’s Latex topper option provides more buoyant support. Made from 100% certified organic latex, it comes in a medium soft firmness level, which is great for those who sleep primarily on their sides. Latex mattress toppers, just like latex mattresses, are naturally hypoallergenic making it a good option for those who suffer from allergies. Saatva’s organic Latex mattress topper is also naturally more cooling than toppers made from memory foam. An organic mattress topper is also a good option for those who prefer a cleaner, more natural bed. This topper measures 1.5 inches thick.
- High-Density foam – This is Saatva’s firm topper, meant mostly for those who need extra support when lying on their backs and stomachs. As its name suggests, high-density foam is denser, thus making it firmer. It also offers less give and although it is less buoyant than latex, it does not have that stuck in the mud feel, allowing you to sleep on top of the mattress rather than in it. The High-Density foam topper measures 1.5 inches thick.
Saatva’s is one of the most popular mattress toppers on the market, not only because of the wide range of options but because all the materials used in Saatva products are Greenguard Gold certified.
All of Saatva’s mattress toppers feature a naturally breathable and moisture-wicking organic cotton cover with reinforced seams. Unfortunately, the mattress cover is not removable nor washable so should accidents happen, we recommend immediate spot cleaning.
The Saatva mattress topper also feature elastic anchor bands on each side to keep the topper securely in place. There is nothing more annoying than a mattress topper that wobbles with each move you make.
We experienced no off-gassing with any of the Saatva toppers, even with the memory foam topper. If you are familiar with Saatva mattresses though, you might notice the same earthy, cottony smell coming from their mattress topper. This is partly due to the materials used and partly due to the organic cotton cover. It isn’t really an issue – in fact, we quite like the scent – but this might be something to consider if you do mind.
The Saatva mattress topper comes in 7 different sizes and vary in thickness according to their fill type.
- Twin
- Twin XL
- Full
- Queen
- King
- California King
- Split King
Saatva does offer a 180-night home trial for their mattress topper which we truly appreciate as most mattress brands do not offer a sleep trial for toppers. It also comes backed by a 1 year limited warranty.
#4. Ghostbed Memory Foam Topper
Check Current Price | Best for Hot Sleepers | 30% Off Coupon: SLEEPLINE | Review
Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| True memory foam feel | Slight off-gassing |
| Actively cooling | Mattress surface make take getting used to |
| 5 zoned support |
Save 30% with coupon code “SLEEPLINE”
Sleeping hot is definitely a universal issue that all mattress brands seek to address. One surefire way to avoid sleeping hot is to sleep on an actively cooling mattress. Ghostbed offers a 2-stage cooling tech not only with their mattresses but with their mattress topper as well.
As we have previously mentioned, memory foam is notorious for trapping heat. Infused foams are a way for memory foam fans to be able to experience the benefits of memory foam without the heat retention.
Ghostbed’s Memory Foam mattress topper features cooling gel memory foam as well as a cool to the touch cover for additional and immediate cooling. This is, by far, the most cooling mattress topper we have tried.
Just like their gel memory foam mattress, the Ghostbed Memory Foam mattress topper contours to the body, offering ultimate pressure relief. This makes it a great option for those who suffer from chronic body pain such as fibromyalgia. That said, because it’s not going to be as responsive as latex toppers so if you prefer a more responsive mattress topper, you might want to look at the latex toppers we have on our list.
The Ghostbed Memory Foam mattress topper also has 5 targeted comfort zones which you can actually see and feel on its surface. Designed with grooves, swirls and spirals, each zone provides specialized pressure relief for the head, shoulders, torso, legs and feet. The zones also act as air pathways for better air circulation, which helps keep the mattress topper cool.
A medium soft to medium on the mattress firmness scale, the Ghostbed Memory Foam mattress topper is suitable for all sleeper types, including strict side sleepers. Back and stomach sleepers would also feel well supported. I sleep predominantly on my stomach and I never felt as though my hips were too sunk in.
The Ghostbed Memory Foam mattress topper comes with a soft, breathable cotton mattress cover that also doubles as a mattress protector. That’s right, it can cover your entire mattress setup as it is deep pocketed. It is also hypoallergenic, antimicrobial and waterproof. Should any accidents happen though, it can be easily removed and machine washed. The mattress topper also features tight-grip elastic bands to keep it in place.
We did experience a small amount of off-gassing with the Ghostbed mattress topper which is normal, especially for memory foam mattress toppers. A little airing out in a well-ventilated room for a day or two sorted it right out.
The Ghostbed Memory Foam mattress topper comes in 7 different sizes and measures 3 inches thick.
- Twin
- Twin XL
- Full
- Queen
- King
- California King
- Split King
Ghostbed offers a 5-year warranty for their mattress topper. They also offer sleep trials for their mattresses but not for their mattress topper.
Buy: Ghostbed Memory Foam Mattress Topper
#5. Puffy Mattress Topper
Check Current Price | Best for Strict Side Sleepers
Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| 2 firmness options | Stuck in the mud feel |
| Hypoallergenic | May be too thin for some |
| True memory foam feel |
Last but certainly not the least on our best mattress topper list is Puffy’s Memory Foam mattress topper. Whether you have a firm mattress or a soft one, the Puffy mattress topper gives you two firmness options to choose from: soft and firm.
The main pressure point for side sleepers is the shoulder area. A firm sleeping surface often causes grief for strict side sleepers and a plush topper like the Puffy Memory Foam topper could help. If you are a strict back sleeper and your current mattress is getting a little softer with time, a firm mattress topper is what you need.
Puffy’s mattress topper offers a true memory foam feel that adapts to the curves and contours of your body, allowing for maximum pressure relief. This also means you may get that stuck in the mud feel, especially if you’re the type of sleeper who switches sleeping positions often. Heavier individuals especially, might actually opt for firmer memory foam toppers as a plush mattress topper might not give them the support they need.
Unlike most memory foam toppers, the Puffy Memory Foam mattress topper is hypoallergenic. This helps keep bacteria and dust mites away and would be a good option for those who are sensitive to allergens.
While it is not the best cooling mattress topper we have tried, the Puffy mattress topper’s cover did a great job of wicking body heat and moisture away. Made of 40% bamboo and 60% polyester, the mattress cover is cool to the touch and breathable all throughout. The removable cover is also machine washable, making it easier to clean should any spills or accidents happen.
The Puffy mattress topper comes with deep elastic pockets that helps hold the topper securely in place. It can be used with mattresses as thick as 15 inches and goes with any mattress type, be it foam, hybrids or an innerspring mattress.
The Puffy mattress topper sits snugly and securely in place thanks to the anti-slip grip on its base. It allows the mattress topper to meld with your current mattress so there’s no danger of your topping slipping off during any type of movement on the mattress surface.
Puffy recommends the use of a mattress protector with your new mattress topper to help keep it fresh and clean, just like you would do with a new mattress.
We did experience a tiny amount of off-gassing with the Puffy mattress topper but this is normal, especially with memory foam.
The Puffy Memory foam mattress topper comes in 6 sizes and measures 2.5 inches thick.
- Twin
- Twin XL
- Full
- Queen
- King
- California King
Puffy offers a 101 night sleeper trial as well as free returns for their memory foam mattress topper. It also comes backed with a lifetime warranty.
Buy: Puffy Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Quick view and comparison
| Brand | myWooly Latex Topper | Lift by Amerisleep | Saatva Mattress Topper | Ghostbed Memory Foam mattress topper | Puffy Mattress Topper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sizes | 6 | 6 | 7 | 7 | 6 |
| Thickness (inches) | 3 | 3 | 3/1.5 | 3 | 2.5 |
| Feel | Plush | Firm/Soft | Medium | Medium Soft to Medium | Soft/Firm |
| Sleeper type | All | All | All | All | All |
| Removable cover | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Sleep trial (nights) | No | No | 180 | No | 101 |
| Warranty (years) | 5 | 5 | 1 | 5 | Lifetime |
| Link to buy | Buy myWooly Latex Topper | Buy Lift by Amerisleep | Buy Saatva Mattress Topper | Buy Ghostbed Mattress Topper | Buy Puffy Mattress Topper |
Why should I buy a mattress topper?
Although not necessarily a necessity, mattress toppers come in handy when you need to adjust the firmness level of your mattress without having to spring for an entirely new mattress.
Mattresses can be expensive – especially premium quality ones – and switching mattresses when they’re still good to go can not only be pricey but wasteful. Mattress toppers can help eliminate the need to buy a new mattress when your old mattress is still in good condition but you want to alter its firmness level.
What features should I look for in a mattress topper?
Much like mattresses, the features to look out for in a mattress topper are its firmness, comfortability, breathability as well as material type.
- Firmness – Soft mattress toppers are great for strict side sleepers, Medium toppers can accommodate all sleeper types while firmer mattress toppers are good for strict stomach sleepers and back sleepers
- Comfortability – There are only 2 reasons why you chose a mattress topper and that’s to either make your mattress softer or firmer. Once again, sleeping positions come into play when it comes to comfort levels. While plushy mattresses sound nice, they will not be able to give enough support to those who sleep primarily on their sides and backs. Firmer mattresses, on the other hand, will create more pressure point issues for those who sleep on their sides. Body weight may also affect how a mattress topper feels. As a general rule, the heavier the individual, the softer a mattress becomes; the lighter, the firmer.
- Breathability – Heat retention can be an issue especially with a traditional memory foam mattress topper. Thankfully, most mattress brands nowadays offer mattress toppers made with memory foam alternatives or latex foam which help wick heat away.
- Material – Most mattress toppers are usually made with foam. This can either be memory foam, a memory foam alternative, gel-infused memory foam or latex foam. Each type of foam offer different features that can suit every individual need and preference. Topper materials can run the gamut from natural and organic foam to man-made polyfoam.
Mattress Toppers vs. Mattress Pads vs. Mattress Protectors
Although mattress toppers, mattress pads and protectors all go on top of a mattress, their similarity ends there. Aside from the fact that they can extend the life span of a mattress, they each serve a different purpose.
- Mattress topper – Toppers are used to significantly change a mattress surface’s firmness and are typically made of thicker foam. Toppers can also extend the longevity of your mattress while providing extra pressure relief and comfortability.
- Mattress pad – Mattress pads can increase a mattress’ comfortability but cannot significantly change a mattress’ firmness level. They are also used to protect a mattress from accidents and dirt. They are usually thinner and have a waterproof bottom.
- Mattress protector – Mattress protectors are thin sheets of stain and water-resistant fabric that go around the edges and the tops of a mattress. They are meant to be used to protect a mattress from any spills or accidents.
FAQs
Does a mattress topper really help?
Using a mattress topper does increase a mattress’ longevity while providing comfortability by increasing or decreasing a mattress surface’s firmness.
Is a thicker mattress topper better?
It is the foam type used that can cause significant changes to a mattress while thicknesses may only add height. On the same vein, thicker toppers are also usually made to be softer, so those who prefer softer mattresses usually go for a thick mattress topper.
What is the best mattress topper type?
The best mattress topper is the one that suits your body type, sleeping position and particular preferences.
Are mattress toppers a waste of money?
Mattress toppers can actually help you save money by extending the life span of your old mattress.
What can I use instead of a mattress topper?
Just like mattresses, toppers are made from foam layers or fills. If you wish to, you can DIY your own mattress topper just like you can DIY your own mattress.
Michelline loves nothing more than a cozy bed, with a stack of books at her side. She loves getting lost when she travels, can bake an entire British afternoon tea from scratch, is obsessed with all things analogue and does calligraphy on the side. She currently suffers from mild insomnia and is more than happy to be your guinea pig, so you won’t have to go through all the trouble of finding out what works best for you.
- Is buying a floor model mattress worth it? - September 2, 2025
- Best mattresses with Affirm financing – data-backed performance tests - August 27, 2025
- Best mattresses – data-backed performance tests on 20+ brands - August 17, 2025
Psst… the sleep review industry is full of liars, sharks, and thieves. It’s a modern-day version of getting ripped off at your local mattress store. So, why should you trust us?