At times we are compensated for the links you click at no cost to you. Learn more about why you should trust our reviews and view our disclosure page.
You want to know which mattress brands are receiving positive feedback on Reddit? You can sit back and relax because we’ve already done all the hard work for you. We spent dozens of hours reading every single best mattress list on all mattress subs to determine the top 10 best mattresses based on Reddit reviews. The overall best mattress for Redditors is the Bear Elite Hybrid.
Top 10 best mattresses based on Reddit reviews:
#1. Bear Elite Hybrid
Why it’s the overall best
After poring over hundreds upon hundreds of Reddit user reviews, the Bear Elite Hybrid always seems to come out on top.
Redditors like it so much because it’s a high-quality mattress that provides all the essential benefits needed to get better sleep.
It’s 14 inches tall, and it has a supportive hybrid design, which means it contains both proprietary foam and pocketed coils.
We also like that it’s available in three firmness levels, so different individuals can choose the best option for their unique needs.
The Bear Elite Hybrid showed excellent results in all our performance tests, and its only drawbacks are its high price point and a new mattress smell upon unboxing.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 14 inches |
| Firmness levels | Soft, Medium, Firm |
| Materials | Phase change material, Celliant, copper-infused memory foam, individually wrapped coils, high densisty foam |
| Free trial period | 120 nights |
| Warranty length | Lifetime |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US, Greenguard Gold |
Bear Elite Hybrid performance
The Bear Elite Hybrid comes in three firmness options: Soft (4.5), Medium (6), and Firm (7).
If you aren’t familiar with the numbers beside each version yet, take a quick look at our article on the mattress firmness scale.
This makes it a versatile mattress that can accommodate most individuals, regardless of their body type or sleeping position.
The Bear Elite Hybrid has an 800 lb. weight capacity, which also makes it a durable option for heavyweight sleepers.
For more heavy-duty mattresses, check out our article on the best mattress for a heavy person.
The Bear Elite Hybrid got a 9.8 in our pressure relief test.
It gave me exceptional contouring and pressure relief while I was sleeping on my back and side. I also felt that my weight was evenly distributed across the mattress, which helped alleviate tension in my lower back.
The Bear Elite Hybrid got a 9.6 in our responsiveness test.
It was really easy to roll around and switch sleeping positions on the mattress. I recommend it for combination sleepers, as well as individuals who have mobility issues. You’ll get a good amount of bounce and responsiveness from the pocketed coil system underneath the foam layers.
The Bear Elite Hybrid got a 9.5 in our cooling test.
It sleeps really cool for a mattress with memory foam, which is notorious for heat retention. This is because the memory foam layer on the mattress is infused with copper, which helps wick away moisture and dissipate heat. Copper is also known to have antimicrobial properties.
On top of that (literally), the mattress has a proprietary cooling cover that’s made with a blend of phase change material and Celliant fiber.
The cover felt cool to the touch, and the phase change material was effective at drawing away body heat and keeping me cool.
And if you aren’t familiar with Celliant fiber yet, studies have shown that it aids in temperature regulation and muscle recovery. This makes the Bear Elite Hybrid a great mattress for athletes or individuals who lead an active lifestyle.
The Bear Elite Hybrid got a 9.6 in our motion isolation test.
The cross-mattress motion transfer on the mattress was minimal to none. You won’t be feeling smaller movements from the opposite side of the bed, but you might feel some motion transfer if somebody (partner or pet) gets in and out of bed.
The Bear Elite Hybrid got a 9.5 in our edge support test.
I thought I would sink a bit more on the edge of the bed, but it was almost as supportive as the middle of the mattress. It showed solid edge support. This means you can maximize the entire surface of the bed and even sleep near the edges.
Overall, the Bear Elite Hybrid mattress garnered a performance rating of 9.6 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Soft/Medium/Firm |
| Cooling | 9.5 |
| Pressure relief | 9.8 |
| Motion transfer | 9.4 |
| Edge support | 9.2 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 14 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (days) | 120 |
| Warranty (years) | Lifetime |
Alternate pick: Bear Original
If you prefer all-foam beds over hybrids, check out the Bear Original mattress.
It has great quality, and it’s one of the best memory foam beds for budget shoppers. It’s made with cooling gel memory foam, and it’s encased in a breathable Tencel cover that absorbs moisture to keep you cool and fresh. In terms of firmness, the Bear Original is medium-firm, and is suitable for all sleeper types.
#2. Naturepedic EOS Classic
Why it’s one of the best
In terms of customizable beds, Redditors have been loving the Naturepedic EOS Classic.
It’s a unique eco-friendly mattress that you can customize by choosing the firmness of its layers. You can select latex foam layers ranging from Plush all the way to Extra-Firm.
It’s also a great mattress for couples with varying firmness preferences.
For queen-size and above, you get a split firmness design so you can adjust your side of the bed to your however you like.
Another thing that Reddit users really like about the EOS Classic is that it has replaceable components which makes for a sustainable mattress.
The Naturepedic EOS Classic did great in all our performance tests, except for the edge support category.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 12 inches |
| Firmness levels | Customizable |
| Materials | Organic cotton, organic wool, organic latex, glue-less individually encased coils |
| Free trial period | 100 nights |
| Warranty length | 25 years |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | GOLS, GOTS, Greenguard Gold |
Naturepedic EOS Classic performance
You can customize the layers of your Naturepedic EOS Classic using five firmness levels: Plush (4), Medium (5), Cushion-Firm (6.5), Firm (7), and Extra-Firm (8).
We felt some nice cushioning from the top quilted layer of the mattress, but it still retained that bouncy and resilient natural latex feel.
We recommend the Naturepedic EOS Classic for eco-conscious shoppers, couples, and individuals of all sleeping positions.
Couples with different firmness tastes can customize their own side of the bed through the split firmness design (queen-size and bigger versions).
The Naturepedic EOS Classic got a 9.6 in our pressure relief test.
Personally, I felt the most cushioning and pressure relief while side sleeping on the Plush and Medium versions. But when I tried back sleeping, the Cushion-Firm and Firm versions gave me the best contouring and support.
The Naturepedic EOS Classic got a 9.5 in our responsiveness test.
It was easy to roll around and switch positions while lying on the mattress. Organic latex is naturally bouncy and responsive compared to other foam types. The EOS Classic mattress also has a supportive coil unit which further increases the bed’s bounce.
The Naturepedic EOS Classic got a 9.5 in our cooling test.
I’m a hot sleeper, and I slept pretty much temperature-neutral on this mattress. It’s more breathable than a memory foam bed because natural latex is perforated for better airflow. I recommend this mattress if you tend to sleep hot.
The Naturepedic EOS Classic (queen-size) got a 9.7 in our motion isolation test.
We tested the queen-size version and we noticed little to no motion transfer. This is because the mattress is split in the middle, so couples can not only get different firmness levels on each side, they basically have their own mattress wherein they feel virtually no cross mattress movement.
The Naturepedic EOS Classic got an 8.7 in our edge support test.
I sank in a bit too much while lying on the edge of the bed. This is the only major drawback we found with this mattress. I don’t recommend sleeping near the edge of the mattress.
Overall, the Naturepedic EOS Classic garnered a performance rating of 9.4 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Customizable |
| Cooling | 9.3 |
| Pressure relief | 9.5 |
| Motion transfer | 8.7 |
| Edge support | 9.7 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 12 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (days) | 100 |
| Warranty (years) | 25 |
Alternate pick: Naturepedic EOS Pillow Top
Looking for a natural latex mattress that has more of a luxurious, plush feel?
Check out the Naturepedic EOS Pillow Top Mattress. It’s also fully customizable, but it’s thicker and softer than the EOS Classic. At 15 inches tall, this is a premium organic mattress that’s right up there with the likes of the Avocado Green and Saatva Zenhaven mattresses.
#3. The Winkbed
Why it’s one of the best
The Winkbed mattress is the best mattress for back pain according to Reddit reviews.
It’s a high-quality hybrid mattress that contains both innerspring coils and gel-infused memory foam for balanced comfort and support.
It’s 13.5 inches tall, and it comes in three firmness options, plus a heavy-duty version that’s designed for heavier individuals.
The Winkbed mattress has more of a innerspring mattress feel, but it also offers ample pressure relief for all body types and sleeping positions.
It showed excellent results in all our performance tests, and its only (minor) drawbacks are its relatively high price and a new mattress smell after unboxing.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 13.5 inches |
| Firmness levels | Softer, Luxury Firm, Firmer, Plus |
| Materials | Tencel cover, gel memory foam, zoned pocketed coils |
| Free trial period | 120 nights |
| Warranty length | Lifetime |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US |
The Winkbed performance
The Winkbed’s main three firmness options are: Softer (4.5), Luxury Firm (6.5), and Firmer (7.5).
The mattress also comes in a heavy-duty model called Plus. This version is highly supportive and durable, and it can accommodate individuals who weigh up to 500 lbs.
We recommend the Winkbed mattress for all body types and sleeping styles, as well as those who suffer from back pain.
It features zoned pocketed coils that are firmer in the middle third of the mattress, where your lower back and hips are. This ensures that you get a neutral spinal alignment to help reduce back pain while also helping to improve your posture.
The Winkbed mattress got a 9.8 in our pressure relief test.
Our test showed that it provided the most pressure relief when we were sleeping on our backs on the mattress. I got full body contouring, and I felt no pain or tension build up in my lower back. I also felt decent cushioning and pressure relief on my hip and shoulder when I switched to a side sleeping position.
The Winkbed mattress got a 9.7 in our responsiveness test.
The pocketed coils give the mattress a bouncy and responsive feel which made it so easy to switch between sleeping positions. We recommend this mattress to combination sleepers and elderly people who have lower mobility.
The Winkbed mattress got a 9.1 in our cooling test.
I slept comfortably and I didn’t feel any heat retention on the mattress. The gel beads in the memory foam layer dissipate body heat to keep you cool. Plus, the coils also provide ample room for airflow.
The Winkbed mattress got a 9.5 in our motion isolation test.
I felt very little motion transfer to my side of the bed when I tried the mattress out with a partner. This means that the individually-wrapped coils are indeed effective at reducing motion transfer.
The Winkbed got a 9.7 in our edge support test.
The mattress has reinforced edges which made me feel stable as I was sleeping on the edge of the bed. It’s one of the best-performing mattresses in the online space in terms of edge support.
Overall, the Winkbed garnered a performance rating of 9.6 out of 10.
We go into more details about this mattress in our full Winkbed review.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Softer/Firmer/Plus |
| Cooling | 9.1 |
| Pressure relief | 9.8 |
| Motion transfer | 8.9 |
| Edge support | 9.7 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 13.5 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (nights) | 120 |
| Warranty (years) | Lifetime |
Alternate pick: Winkbeds GravityLux
Not a big fan of coil mattresses? Winkbeds also has an all-foam alternative called the Winkbeds GravityLux mattress.
It’s a high-end mattress that contains proprietary AirCell™ memory foam and high-density support foam. It provides great comfort and pressure relief, and it’s also slightly cheaper than the Winkbed mattress.
#4. Nolah Original Hybrid
Why it’s one of the best
As for hybrid mattresses, the Nolah Original Hybrid is the best according to Reddit reviews.
Redditors like it because it’s an affordable hybrid mattress that uses a proprietary foam that’s more supportive and breathable than classic memory foam.
It’s 11 inches tall, and it has a balanced foam feel that fits a wide range of individuals and sleeping positions. It’s also more supportive than average because of its hybrid coil and foam design.
The Nolah Original Hybrid showed good results in all our performance tests, except for the edge support category.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 11 inches |
| Firmness levels | Medium Firm |
| Materials | Botanic tencel, zoned AirFoam, EverAdapt transition foam, HDMax Tri-Zone coils |
| Free trial period | 120 nights |
| Warranty length | Lifetime |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US |
Nolah Original Hybrid performance
We rated the Nolah Original Hybrid at 6.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale.
It has a neutral foam feel that kept me on top of the bed rather than sinking into it. It’s medium-firm in terms of firmness, and it’s suitable for all sleeper types.
That said, we do not recommend it for stomach sleepers who weigh over 250 lbs. If you’re a plus-size stomach sleeper, we suggest that you opt for a firmer mattress.
The Nolah Original Hybrid got a 9.5 in our pressure relief test.
We felt a good amount of cushioning and pressure relief without feeling stuck in the mattress. For me personally, this mattress gave me better pressure relief while I was back sleeping rather than side sleeping.
The Nolah Original Hybrid got a 9.5 in our responsiveness test.
It showed higher responsiveness than most memory foam beds, but it wasn’t as good as some other hybrid models that we’ve tested. Still, we do recommend it for combination sleepers and individuals with mobility issues.
The Nolah Original Hybrid got a 9.1 in our cooling test.
Its open-cell foam structure and pocketed coil system allow for more airflow than the average memory foam mattress. It’s a good option for those who tend to sleep hot at night.
The Nolah Original Hybrid got a 9.5 in our motion isolation test.
We noticed minimal cross-mattress motion transfer on the mattress. However, bigger movements, such as getting in and out of bed, did transfer to the other side.
The Nolah Original Hybrid got an 8.9 in our edge support test.
It showed below-average edge support, especially for a hybrid mattress. We experienced deep sinkage when we slept near the edge of the mattress.
Overall, the Nolah Original Hybrid mattress garnered a performance rating of 9.3 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium Firm |
| Cooling | 9.1 |
| Pressure relief | 9.5 |
| Motion transfer | 9.3 |
| Edge support | 8.9 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 11 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (nights) | 120 |
| Warranty (years) | Lifetime |
Alternate pick: Nolah Evolution 15
Are you a plus-size sleeper? A better alternative for heavy people would be the Nolah Evolution 15.
As its name suggests, it’s a 15-inch mattress that features a supportive hybrid construction to provide lasting comfort and support for individuals who weigh up to 500 lbs. It works for all body types as well as all sleeping positions (more on this in our full Nolah Evolution 15 mattress review).
#5. Saatva Classic
Why it’s one of the best
The Saatva Classic is the best innerspring mattress, according to Reddit user reviews.
Innerspring mattresses are still very popular today, and Redditors like that the Saatva Classic is a more modern model that doesn’t have the drawbacks of traditional coil mattresses.
It comes in two heights, 11.5″ and 14.5″, and it’s available in multiple firmness levels. It has a durable, high-quality construction and zoned pocketed coils to provide support where your body needs it most.
The Saatva Classic showed great results in most of our performance tests, and its only downsides are its poor motion isolation and that it might be too firm for some side sleepers.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 11.5 inches, 14.5 inches |
| Firmness levels | Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, Firm |
| Materials | Organic cotton cover with Guardin, high density memory foam, Lumbar Zone coils |
| Free trial period | 365 nights |
| Warranty length | Lifetime |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US, Greenguard Gold |
Saatva Classic performance
The Saatva Classic comes in the following firmness levels: Plush Soft (4), Luxury Firm (6.5-7), and Firm (8).
We found that each of these versions has the same responsive and bouncy innerspring feel. We recommend the Saatva Classic for all body types and sleeping positions, as well as for individuals who prefer coil mattresses.
However, some side sleepers might find the mattress too firm for their hips and shoulders. In this case, we suggest looking for a mattress with better cushioning and pressure relief.
The Saatva Classic mattress got a 9.4 in our pressure relief test.
I felt some pressure on my shoulder when I was lying on my side, but I felt great body contouring and pressure relief when I switched to a back sleeping position. I would recommend this mattress for those who suffer from back pain since it has zoned support, which promotes proper spinal alignment.
The Saatva Classic mattress got a 9.9 in our responsiveness test.
It has the highest responsiveness score out of all the beds we’ve tested so far. We highly recommend it for combo sleepers, as well as people with low mobility.
The Saatva Classic mattress got a 9.4 in our cooling test.
I slept quite cool on the mattress and I didn’t notice any heat retention on its surface. And although it doesn’t contain any active cooling materials, its coil system alone helps promote continuous airflow.
The Saatva Classic mattress got an 8.7 in our motion isolation test.
It showed moderate to high levels of cross-mattress motion transfer. It’s not the best option if you don’t want your sleep to be interrupted by your partner’s movements.
The Saatva Classic mattress got a 9.8 in our edge support test.
This result is better than 90% of the mattresses we’ve tested so far. We felt sturdy support when we moved towards the edge of the bed.
Overall, the Saatva Classic garnered a performance rating of 9.4 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Plush Soft/Luxury Firm/Firm |
| Cooling | 8.9 |
| Pressure relief | 9.2 |
| Motion transfer | 8.7 |
| Edge support | 9.8 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 11.5/14.5 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (days) | 365 |
| Warranty (years) | Lifetime |
Alternate pick: Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid
If you’re looking for a more body-hugging feel, check out the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid.
It’s a hybrid mattress that’s made with proprietary AirCradle® memory foam and durable pocketed coils. It has a medium-firm feel, and it provides comfort and support for all body types and sleeping positions.
#6. Purple Mattress
Why it’s one of the best
The Purple Mattress is the best cooling mattress according to Reddit reviews.
It has one of the most unique and innovative designs on the market with its GelFlex® Grid. Made from hyper-elastic polymer, this proprietary gel grid acts as the bed’s main comfort layer in lieu of foam.
It’s 9.25 inches tall, and it has a medium-firm feel that’s suitable for all sleeper types. It’s also a great mattress for hot sleepers because its GelFlex® Grid promotes airflow and cooling.
The Purple Mattress did very well in all our performance tests, except for the edge support category, where it scored below average.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 9.25 inches |
| Firmness levels | Medium Firm |
| Materials | SoftFlex cover, GelFLex grid, edge support foam, Adaptive Comfort foam, base support foam |
| Free trial period | 100 nights |
| Warranty length | 10 years |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US |
Purple Mattress performance
We gave the Purple Mattress a 6.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale.
However, it might feel a bit firmer for individuals who weigh below 130 lbs. We found the mattress to be highly responsive, and its GelFlex grid kind of made me feel like I was floating on top of the bed.
This mattress is suitable for all sleeper types, but we found that it works best for back sleepers. It provided decent support for spinal alignment, and it also gave us some good pressure relief.
That said, it’s not going to be supportive enough for heavy-set individuals (over 300 lbs.). If you’re a plus-size sleeper, we recommend getting a mattress with a pocketed coil support unit.
The Purple Mattress got a 9.5 in our pressure relief test.
I didn’t get much pressure relief on my side, but I felt really comfortable lying on my back. I liked the unique feel of the GelFlex® grid. It’s a bit similar to the buoyant feel of natural latex, and it provided adequate support to keep my spine in a neutral alignment.
The Purple Mattress got a 9.7 in our responsiveness test.
The GelFlex® grid is highly responsive and bouncy. It was extremely easy for us to roll around and switch sleeping positions while lying on the mattress.
The Purple Mattress got a 9.7 in our cooling test.
It slept cooler than 88% of the mattresses we’ve tested so far. The GelFlex® grid’s convoluted design allows for continuous airflow, and it has much better cooling performance than memory foam or polyfoam. We highly recommend the Purple Mattress for hot sleepers.
The Purple Mattress got a 9.3 in our motion isolation test.
I thought that since it had a good amount of bounce, it would have high motion transfer. But that wasn’t the case. We noticed low to moderate amounts of motion transfer on this mattress.
The Purple Mattress got an 8.9 in our edge support test.
This score is below average because we did not get adequate support while lying on the edge of the mattress. You’ll find better edge support on an innerspring or a hybrid mattress.
Overall, the Purple Mattress garnered a performance rating of 9.4 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium |
| Cooling | 8.9 |
| Pressure relief | 9.8 |
| Motion transfer | 8.8 |
| Edge support | 9.6 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 9.25 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (nights) | 100 nights |
| Warranty (years) | 10 |
Alternate pick: Purple RestorePlus Hybrid
If you’re looking for a thicker and more supportive mattress, check out the new Purple RestorePlus Hybrid.
It’s a premium hybrid mattress that’s made with the GelFlex® Grid, soft foam, and zoned pocketed coils. It’s 13 inches tall, and it comes in two firmness options to accommodate a wide array of sleepers.
#7. Emma Hybrid Comfort
Why it’s one of the best
The Emma Hybrid Comfort is the best budget-friendly mattress based on Reddit user reviews.
Redditors like it because it provides similar benefits as some costlier bed-in-a-box hybrid mattresses.
It’s 13 inches tall, and it has a medium-firm feel that’s suitable for most individuals and sleeping styles.
The Emma Hybrid Comfort performed well in most of our tests, and its only drawbacks are poor edge support and some initial off-gassing upon unboxing.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 13 inches |
| Firmness levels | Medium Firm |
| Materials | Moisture wicking cover, pocketed coils, proprietary foam |
| Free trial period | 365 nights |
| Warranty length | 10 years |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US |
Emma Hybrid Comfort performance
We rated the Emma Hybrid Comfort at 6.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale.
This is the industry standard for medium-firm, and it can be a good fit for a wide variety of sleepers.
In terms of feel, the Emma Hybrid Comfort has a neutral foam feel that kept me on top of the mattress rather than sinking into it.
However, we don’t recommend it for stomach sleepers who weigh well over 250 lbs. If you are, we suggest that you opt for a firmer mattress that will keep your hips propped up on the bed.
The Emma Hybrid Comfort mattress got a 9.6 in our pressure relief test.
I felt nice body-hugging comfort and pressure relief on my sides as well as on my back. The zoned support system also worked well in keeping my spine in a neutral alignment, no matter what sleeping position I was in.
The Emma Hybrid Comfort mattress got a 9.7 in our responsiveness test.
I didn’t experience any difficulty while moving around and switching positions on the mattress. It’s a great option for combo sleepers and those with mobility issues.
The Emma Hybrid Comfort mattress got a 9 in our cooling test.
I slept at a neutral temperature all night. The mattress doesn’t have any active cooling materials, but its coil system allows for decent air circulation.
The Emma Hybrid Comfort mattress got a 9.7 in our motion isolation test.
The motion transfer on this mattress was minimal to none. We would recommend it for couples and those who share a bed with a pet.
The Emma Hybrid Comfort mattress got an 8.8 in our edge support test.
The result was below average for a hybrid mattress. We don’t recommend sleeping near the edges of this mattress.
Overall, the Emma Hybrid Comfort garnered a performance rating of 9.4 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium Firm |
| Cooling | 9 |
| Pressure relief | 9.6 |
| Motion transfer | 9.1 |
| Edge support | 8.8 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 13 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (days) | 365 |
| Warranty (years) | 10 |
Alternate pick: Emma Shift
We also suggest taking a look at Emma’s top-of-the-line model, the Emma Shift mattress.
It’s a customizable mattress in which you can adjust the firmness until you achieve your desired feel. Its firmness levels range from Medium (5) all the way to Firm (8), and it also features a split firmness design for queen-size models and above.
#8. Sweet Night Prime
Why it’s one of the best
When it comes to memory foam beds, Redditors chose the Sweet Night Prime mattress as their top pick.
We also really like this mattress because it has a dual-sided design, and it features four different firmness zones. Two on top and two on the bottom.
It comes in 10-inch and 12-inch heights, and it’s suitable for most individuals regardless of their preferred sleeping position. The 10-inch model felt slightly firmer, while the 12-inch model offered a bit more comfort and support.
The Sweet Night Prime showed good results in all our performance tests, except for its edge support, which could be better.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 10 inches, 12 inches |
| Firmness levels | Soft, Medium Soft, Medium Firm, Firm |
| Materials | Fabric cover, gel memory foam, high denisty support foam |
| Free trial period | 100 nights |
| Warranty length | 10 years |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US |
Sweet Night Prime performance
The Sweet Night Prime mattress has four firmness zones: Soft and Medium-Soft (top side), and Medium-Firm and Firm (bottom side).
It’s the first mattress we’ve tested that has four firmness zones in one. In terms of feel, it gave me a soft, cradling memory foam feel and a good amount of cushioning and comfort.
We recommend the Sweet Night Prime mattress for all sleeper types.
However, we don’t recommend it for individuals who weigh over 300 lbs. Since it’s an all-foam bed, it doesn’t provide the same level of support as a durable hybrid mattress.
The Sweet Night Prime mattress got a 9.5 in our pressure relief test.
I got some good pressure relief on my shoulders while sleeping on my side. The top memory foam layer evenly distributed my body weight and I felt no tension in my lower back.
The Sweet Night Prime mattress got a 9.3 in our responsiveness test.
The mattress did have a slow-moving memory foam feel, which made me exert a little effort when switching between different sleeping positions. It’s not the best option for combination sleepers and elderly people who have lower mobility.
The Sweet Night Prime mattress got a 9 in our cooling test.
I didn’t experience any heat retention, but I didn’t get much airflow either. We noticed average temperature regulation on this mattress.
The Sweet Night Prime mattress got a 9.5 in our motion isolation test.
As expected, we noticed veryminimal motion transfer during our test. This is common for most memory foam mattresses because memory foam is great at isolating motion on one side of the bed.
The Sweet Night Prime mattress got an 8.7 in our edge support test.
The results were below average. If edge support is a major factor for you, this isn’t the mattress for you.
Overall, the Sweet Night Prime mattress garnered a performance rating of 9.2 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Soft to Firm |
| Cooling | 8.7 |
| Pressure relief | 9.4 |
| Motion isolation | 9.4 |
| Edge support | 8.7 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 10/12 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (days) | 100 |
| Warranty (years) | 10 |
Alternate pick: Sweet Night Twilight
You’re liking the Sweet Night Prime, but you’re worried about its durability and support. That’s ok. Sweet Night also offers a supportive hybrid mattress called the Sweet Night Twilight.
Ideal for heavier sleepers, the Sweet Night Twilight contains both gel memory foam and pocketed coils to provide a blend of plush comfort and durable support.
#9. Eco Terra Hybrid
Why it’s one of the best
The eco-conscious users of Reddit chose the Eco Terra Hybrid as their top pick for eco-friendly mattresses.
Most reviews say that the Eco Terra Hybrid matters provides the same amount of responsive support and comfort as other, more expensive latex mattresses.
It’s 11 inches tall, and its construction includes natural latex and upcycled steel coils. It’s available in two firmness levels, which makes it a viable option for all sleeper types.
The Eco Terra Hybrid did very well in all our performance tests, except for the motion isolation category.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 11 inches |
| Firmness levels | Medium, Medium Firm |
| Materials | Organic cotton, organic wool, organic latex, quantum coils |
| Free trial period | 90 days |
| Warranty length | 15 years |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | GOLS, GOTS, eco-INSTITUT |
Eco Terra Hybrid performance
In terms of firmness, we rated the Medium version a 5, and the Medium-Firm a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale.
I felt well-supported by the natural latex comfort layer, and I also received a good amount of comfort and pressure relief.
We recommend the Eco Terra Hybrid for all sleeper types: back, side, stomach, and combination.
However, we did notice a lack of support for stomach sleepers who weigh over 300 lbs. Our plus-size tester said that his hips sank excessively into the mattress, which put his spine out of alignment.
If you’re a heavier stomach sleeper, we recommend getting something like the Avocado Green mattress instead.
The Eco Terra Hybrid got a 9.3 in our pressure relief test.
The natural latex layer in the mattress did not provide as much pressure relief as softer memory foam beds. It did give me a bit of sinkage around my hips and shoulders, but it might not be comfortable enough for some strict side sleepers.
That being said, I did get a lot of comfort when I slept on my back on the mattress. My body weight was evenly distributed, and I almost felt like I was floating on top of the bed.
The Eco Terra Hybrid got a 9.7 in our responsiveness test.
It showed a quick response to pressure and high levels of bounce. This enabled me to move and switch between different sleeping positions with relative ease.
The Eco Terra Hybrid got a 9.1 in our cooling test.
I slept at a neutral temperature on this mattress. There was no noticeable heat retention, and the perforated structure of its latex layer allows airflow through the mattress.
The Eco Terra Hybrid got an 8.8 in our motion isolation test.
We felt moderate to high motion transfer on the mattress. We expected as much because natural latex is inherently bouncy, and the pocketed coils add a bit of bounce as well.
The Eco Terra Hybrid got a 9.5 in our edge support test.
It scored high because we felt well-supported while sleeping near its edges. We also got sturdy support when we tried sitting on the edge of the bed.
Overall, the Eco Terra Hybrid mattress garnered a performance rating of 9.3 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium/Medium Firm |
| Cooling | 9.1 |
| Pressure relief | 9.3 |
| Motion transfer | 8.8 |
| Edge support | 9.5 |
| Mattress thickness | 11 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (days) | 90 |
| Warranty (years) | 15 |
#10. Latex for Less Hybrid
Why it’s one of the best
Reddit users like the Latex for Less Hybrid because it’s an eco-friendly latex hybrid mattress that fits a wide range of individuals and sleeping positions.
It’s made with organic Dunlop latex and wool, and it contains a pocketed coil system to provide durable and responsive support.
It’s 12 inches tall, and it comes in two firmness levels, so you can choose which one works best for you.
The Latex for Less Hybrid showed good results in all our performance tests, except for the edge support category in which it scored below average.
Specs at a glance
| Thickness levels | 12 inches |
| Firmness levels | Medium, Firm |
| Materials | Organic, organic Dunlop latex, fabric encased coils |
| Free trial period | 120 nights |
| Warranty length | 20 years |
| Shipping | Free |
| Certification | GOLS, GOTS |
Latex for Less Hybrid performance
We rated the Medium version a 5 and the Firm version a 7.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale.
We discovered that the Firm model gave us more bounce and support, while the Medium model provided better contouring.
We recommend the Latex for Less Hybrid mattress for most individuals, regardless of their primary sleeping position.
The Latex for Less Hybrid mattress got a 9.6 in our pressure relief test.
I experienced significant pressure relief, especially in the area around my lower back, while lying on the Medium version. The Firm model, on the other hand, offers extra support and helps promote proper spinal alignment.
The Latex for Less Hybrid mattress got a 9.6 in our responsiveness test.
We found it easy to move about and change positions on the mattress. The organic latex layer gives the mattress bounce and a quick response to pressure and movement.
The Latex for Less Hybrid mattress got a 9.3 in our cooling test.
I felt quite cool while sleeping on the mattress because its natural latex layer is perforated for airflow. We recommend this mattress to hot sleepers who are looking a bed that doesn’t trap body heat.
The Latex for Less Hybrid mattress got a 9.2 in our motion isolation test.
Although latex mattresses generally have a strong bounce and motion transfer, this mattress did a great job of isolating motion. We experienced minimal motion transfer during our testing.
The Latex for Less Hybrid mattress got a 9.3 in our edge support test.
It works well for sleeping close to the bed’s edge, but it’s not ideal for sitting. I noticed a significant compression of the foam layers when I sat on the edge of the mattress.
Overall, the Latex for Less Hybrid garnered a performance rating of 9.4 out of 10.
| Factor | Performance |
|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium, Firm |
| Cooling | 9.3 |
| Pressure relief | 9.6 |
| Motion isolation | 9.2 |
| Edge support | 9.3 |
| Mattress thickness (inches) | 12 |
| Sinkage | Minimal |
| Trial (nights) | 120 |
| Warranty (years) | 20 |
Alternate pick: Latex for Less Natural
The Latex for Less Natural mattress is a coil-free alternative to the Latex for Less Hybrid.
It’s a dual-sided mattress, with a Medium-Firm side on one side and a Firm side on the other. It comes in two height profiles, and it’s an excellent option for those on a budget who are looking for a good-quality natural latex mattress.
How we picked these mattresses
A quality mattress should provide a decent blend of support, comfort, and durability. Reddit users selected mattresses that meet these criteria well – and you know how judgy Redditors can be so you can be sure that you’re getting the best .
They also considered factors like price, comfort, temperature regulation, firmness, certifications, and durability. In addition to all of that, we also made sure that all the mattresses in this list are backed by sustainability and safety certifications.
Here’s a brief description of each factor we considered while making this list:
- Durability – A quality mattress should last between 7 to 10 years. We researched each brand’s reputation and warranty offerings. We also tested the materials used to see if they can withstand heavy loads without compromising their structural integrity.
- Firmness – Everyone has their preferred level of firmness, whether it’s soft, medium, or firm. We looked for mattresses that can suit a wide variety of body types and sleeping positions. Most mattresses in the list have at least two firmness levels, and some beds are dual-sided.
- Temperature regulation – We specifically looked for mattresses that are made of cool, breathable, and durable materials. Sleep quality can be affected by overheating at night. That’s why we chose mattresses that have good temperature regulation and can maintain a temperature-neutral surface all night.
- Comfort – We looked for beds that offer the right balance of comfort and support. We examined the materials and construction of each mattress, and we narrowed it down to those that excel in pressure relief and body contouring.
- Price – We looked for mattresses that offer a great balance of comfort and support for the money. We considered the longevity of each mattress to determine if it’s going to be a worthwhile investment for you.
- Certifications – We only recommend mattresses that are backed by environmental and safety certifications. Some certifications that we look out for are CertiPUR-US and GreenGuard Gold for foam beds, and GOTS and GOLS for natural and organic mattresses.
Additional resources: learn more about Reddit’s favorite mattress
Conclusion
Based on what we’ve seen and read from countless Reddit users, the consensus is that they want to get a better mattress to improve their sleep quality and health. Many Redditors have shared their preferred mattresses and brands, and we based our list on their reviews. We did our best to include mattresses that are suitable for different types of individuals, budgets, and sleeping styles.
If you still can’t decide on a mattress, go for the Bear Elite Hybrid. It’s the overall best mattress, according to Reddit reviews, and it offers great value and multiple important benefits to help improve your sleep.
How we rate mattresses
We personally test and rate mattresses using the following strict quantitative criteria:
Learn more about our mattress rating process and methodology here.
Aside from writing articles on mattresses and other sleep products and topics, Siegfried is a guitarist, athlete, and book lover.
- Best mattresses made in the USA – data-driven performance tests - April 25, 2024
- Best Tempur-Pedic mattress – data-backed performance test results - March 26, 2024
- Best hotel mattress – data-backed performance tests on 14+ brands - March 21, 2024
Psst… the sleep review industry is full of liars, sharks, and thieves. It’s a modern-day version of getting ripped off at your local mattress store. So, why should you trust us?