Home » Mattresses » Best queen-size mattresses – hands-on tests on 20+ brands

Best queen-size mattresses – hands-on tests on 20+ brands

At times we are compensated for the links you click at no cost to you. Learn more about why you should trust our reviews and view our disclosure page.

Table of Contents

Queen is the most common mattress size. Since they’re so common, it’s hard to tell them apart. Which ones are worth buying and which ones are duds? I went through the hard work of testing out all of the leading brands to find out for myself. My overall favorite queen-size mattress is the Bear Elite Hybrid.

Save 35% with coupon code SLEEPLINE35


Top ten best queen-sized mattresses and performance test results

Bear mattress logo

#1. Bear Elite Hybrid

Overall Best

  • Excellent edge support 
  • Supportive and pressure relieving
  • 35% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE35
helix mattress logo

#2. Helix Midnight Luxe

Best for Side Sleepers

  • Offers zoned support 
  • Plush and pressure relieving
  • 20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20
brooklyn bedding logo

#3. Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro

Best for Back Sleepers

  • Offers extra support for back and joints 
  • Good for couples
  • 25% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE25
egohome mattress logo

#4. Egohome Black

Best Affordable

  • Great for side sleepers 
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • 12% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE12
winkbed logo

#5. WinkBeds GravityLux

Best All-Foam Queen-Size

  • Exceptional edge support 
  • Good for back pain
  • Very cooling
Plank logo

#6. Plank Firm Luxe

Best Firm Queen-Size

  • Suitable for heavier-set individuals 
  • Great edge support
  • 25% Off Coupon Code: SLEEPLINE25
Birch mattress logo

#7. Birch Luxe Natural

Best Latex Queen-Size

  • Naturally cooling and hypoallergenic 
  • Offers responsive support
  • 20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20
Glacier mattress brand logo

#8. Glacier Original Hybrid

Best for Stomach Sleepers

  • Offers responsive support 
  • Helps with proper spinal alignment
  • Good for back and stomach sleepers
puffy logo

#9. Puffy Royal

Best Plush Queen-Size

  • Plush and luxurious 
  • Suitable for all sleeper types
  • Pressure relieving
Saatva mattress logo

#10. Saatva Classic

Best High-End Queen-Size

  • Great for couples 
  • Fiberglass-free
  • Comes in 3 different firmness levels

#1. Bear Elite Hybrid

Bear Elite Hybrid queen-size mattress
Bear Elite Hybrid Mattress

Pros

  • Excellent edge support
  • Pressure point relief
  • Choose between three firmness options
  • Cooling

Cons

  • Might be too high for those with limited mobility
  • Slight off-gassing

Save 35% with coupon code SLEEPLINE35

Why it’s the best

The Bear Elite Hybrid is an excellent all-around mattress that’s good for all sleeper types.

We found it difficult to find fault with the Bear Elite Hybrid as it performs pretty well in all categories that matter the most to you and me – from temperature regulation to back support to pressure relief.

It’s a true jack-of-all-trades.

Hence why this is our number one pick when it comes to queen-sized mattresses.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 14 inches
Firmness levels Soft, Medium, Firm
Materials Celliant cover, hand-quilted top, copper-infused memory foam, dynamic transition foam, pocketed steel coils, high density foam layer
Free trial period 120 nights
Warranty length Lifetime
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

Bear Elite Hybrid Performance

You get to choose between three different firmness levels with the Bear Elite Hybrid – soft, medium and firm.

The soft version is best for side sleepers as well as those who suffer from chronic pain.

The medium version is good for all sleeper types including those who switch between different sleeping positions.

The firm version is best for those who sleep primarily on their backs and stomachs.

Since the Bear Elite Hybrid is, as the name implies, a hybrid mattress, it’s great for heavier-set sleepers.

We rate the Bear Elite Hybrid a 9.8 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The combination of coils and copper-infused memory foam work seamlessly together to provide more than enough pressure point relief (no matter your preferred sleeping position).

We rate the Bear Elite Hybrid a 9.5 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Copper has been proven to be a good heat conductor, guiding heat away from the mattress. That plus the substantial coil unit helps to keep heat retention at bay. This in turn helps you sleep cool and fresh throughout the night.

We rate the Bear Elite Hybrid a 9.6 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

Despite the thick coil unit, the foam comfort layers do a good job of absorbing any cross mattress movement. I barely felt any motion transfer when I tried the mattress out with a partner.

We rate the Bear Elite Hybrid a 9.5 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

The mattress contains reinforced edge coils that help provide extra edge support. I felt well-supported even though I’m the type of sleeper who likes to sleep close to the edge of the bed.

Save 35% with coupon code SLEEPLINE35

Alternate pick: Bear Original

Bear Original mattress
Bear Original Mattress

If you prefer something with an all-foam construction, check out the Bear Original mattress.

The Bear Original is not a hybrid (it contains no coils). So if you’re looking for a pure play foam-only mattress, this is the one to buy.

Note also that it’s MUCH cheaper than the Elite Hybrid.

Save 35% with coupon code SLEEPLINE35


#2. Helix Midnight Luxe

Helix Midnight Luxe mattress performance tests
Helix Midnight Luxe

Pros

  • Offers zoned support
  • Plush and pressure relieving
  • Great for strict side sleepers
  • Fiberglass-free

Cons

  • Not suitable for heavier back and stomach sleepers
  • Can be a bit heat-retentive

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

Why it’s one of the best

It’s not very often that you can find a hybrid mattress that can absorb movement the way an all-foam mattress can… but the Helix Midnight Luxe – even with its hundreds of pocketed steel coils – feels more like a memory foam mattress than a hybrid mattress.

And I mean that in the best possible way.

But for all its merits when it comes to motion isolation, I find that it falls a little short in the cooling department – perhaps because of its multiple foam layers (we really can’t have it all can we?).

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 13.5 inches
Firmness levels Medium Firm
Materials Tencel/GlacioTex cooling cover, premium quilted pillow top, Helix responsive foam, copper gel memory foam, Memory Plus foam, recycled steel coils, DuraDense foam
Free trial period 100 nights
Warranty length 15 years
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

Helix Midnight Luxe Performance

The Helix Midnight Luxe sits on a 6 on the mattress firmness scale, giving it a medium-firm feel.

Usually mattresses with a medium-firm feel are good for all sleeper types but I find this one to be a tad too soft right in the middle, which can wreak havoc for a stomach sleeper (especially one who weighs more than average).

We rate the Helix Midnight Luxe an 8.5 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The mattress contains multiple layers of memory foam in addition to a quilted pillow top. This gives it a plusher surface which helps with pressure relief, especially if you sleep on your side.

We rate the Helix Midnight Luxe a 6 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Even though the memory foam is infused with a cooling gel, it still wasn’t enough – I don’t recommend this mattress if you sleep hot.

We rate the Helix Midnight Luxe a 10 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

I’ve already sung the Helix Midnight Luxe’s praises earlier when it comes to motion isolation so it’s no surprise that we rate a solid 10 out of 10. No notes.

We rate the Helix Midnight Luxe a 9 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

This mattress contains reinforced edges, which helps provide more support around the entire perimeter. This also allows you to sleep on more of the mattress surface instead of staying bunched up in the middle.

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

Alternate pick: Helix Dusk Luxe

helix dusk luxe mattress
Helix Dusk Luxe

If you’re a stomach sleeper, you might want to check out the Helix Dusk Luxe.

Similar in construction to the Midnight Luxe, the Dusk Luxe is slightly firmer.

This makes it a better choice for stomach and back sleepers (who need extra support).

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20


#3. Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro

Queen-size Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro mattress in the Sleepline Testing Studio
Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro

Pros

  • Offers extra support for back and joints
  • Good for couples
  • Pressure-relieving
  • Suitable for back sleepers

Cons

  • Might be too firm for petite side sleepers
  • Not suitable for hot sleepers

25% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE25

Why it’s one of the best

In my opinion, the Brooklyn Bedding Copperflex Pro mattress offers a plush and premium pillow top mattress feel without the premium price tag.

Coming in at a medium-firm, the mattress provides the right amount of support, especially if you sleep on your back and/or stomach.

Another thing that I like a lot about this mattress is that you can barely feel any motion transfer (making it a great choice for couples).

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 14 inches
Firmness levels Medium Firm
Materials GlacioTex cooling cover, pressure relieving quilted foam, memory foam, VariFlex transition layer, zoned lumbar support foam, individually wrapped spring coils, high density foam
Free trial period 120 nights
Warranty length 10 years
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro Performance

With its medium-firm to firm firmness level, the Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro is around a 7 on the mattress firmness scale.

This makes it suitable for back and stomach sleepers but may be a little too firm for lightweight side sleepers.

We rate the Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro an 8.5 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The four foam layers provide pressure point relief similar to how a traditional memory foam mattress does but without the dreaded sinkage.

We rate the Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro a 6 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Sure, it contains copper-infused memory foam, which is supposed to actually help with temperature regulation, but for some reason this mattress retains quite a significant amount of heat. I don’t recommend it to someone who sleeps hot.

We rate the Brooklyn Bedding Copperflex Pro an 8 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

The multiple comfort and support foam layers absorb cross-mattress movement quite well. I barely felt any motion transfer when I tried the mattress out with a partner.

We rate the Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Pro a 7.5 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

Though not the worst, the edge support is not the best either – you won’t be rolling off the bed but you will sink into the edge a bit if you sit on it.

25% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE25

Alternate pick: Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe test
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe

If you need something that’s more cooling, take a look at the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe mattress.

Similar in construction to the CopperFlex Pro, the Aurora Luxe is just so much better at wicking away heat.

If you’re a hot sleeper, this is the one you should go with.

25% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE25


#4. Egohome Black

Egohome Black queen mattress size
Egohome Black Mattress

Pros

  • Great for side sleepers
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • Good for those who suffer from chronic pain

Cons

  • Poor edge support
  • Not suitable for heavier-set stomach sleepers

12% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE12

Why it’s one of the best

Not all affordable mattresses work as well as they claim… but the Egohome Black works just as well as a lot of higher-end all-foam mattresses on the market, if not better.

And for less than $1000 to boot.

Featuring layers of memory foam alternatives, the Egohome Black mattress offers the same contouring and compression as traditional memory foam but without any of the sinkage.

The one feature that really stands out is its motion isolation.

I know, I know – all-foam mattresses in general are known to perform very well when it comes to absorbing movement but some are bouncier than others. With this mattress you feel virtually zero movement.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 12 inches/14 inches
Firmness levels Medium Soft, Medium Firm
Materials Graphene cooling mattress cover, copper gel AeroFusion foam, Adaptifoam, liquid gel CoolFlex foam, support foam, fire retardant
Free trial period 100 nights
Warranty length 10 years
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

Egohome Black Performance

You get to choose between two different firmness levels – medium-soft and medium-firm.

Choose the medium-soft version if you’re a side sleeper and opt for the medium-firm version if you’re a back or stomach sleeper.

Since the mattress features an all-foam construction, it won’t be able to fully support you if you weigh more than 250 lbs.

We rate the Egohome Black mattress an 8.5 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The mattress provides enough support for all your main pressure points. It’s very comfortable.

We rate the Egohome Black mattress a 6.5 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

This mattress retains a lot of heat. I certainly don’t recommend it if you’re a hot sleeper.

We rate the Egohome Black mattress a 10 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

This is where the mattress really shines. I did not feel any motion transfer whatsoever when I tried it out with a partner.

We rate the Egohome Black mattress a 6 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

The mattress does not feature reinforced edge coils nor are its edges firm enough to sit on – you will find yourself rolling off the mattress if you sleep on or close to the edge.

12% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE12


#5. WinkBeds GravityLux

WinkBeds GravityLux queen size
WinkBeds Gravity Lux

Pros

  • Good for back pain
  • Exceptional edge support
  • Very cooling
  • Great for couples

Cons

  • Medium version can be too firm for some
  • Slight off-gassing

Why it’s one of the best

The WinkBeds GravityLux is one of the best queen-sized all-foam mattresses that I’ve tried.

It surprisingly does not retain any heat, making it an excellent choice for hot sleepers.

Made from premium memory foam layers, the WinkBeds GravityLux mattress features a simple construction that consists of only four layers. 

But don’t be fooled by its simplicity – each layer packs a punch.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 13.5 inches
Firmness levels Soft, Medium, Firm
Materials Breathable cover, cooling gel-infused memory foam, Aircell memory foam, Progression foam, high density foam layer
Free trial period 120 nights
Warranty length Lifetime warranty
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

WinkBeds GravityLux Performance

You get to choose between three different firmness levels – soft, medium, and firm. 

The soft version is best if you sleep only on your side.

The medium version is good for all sleeper types including combination sleepers.

The firm version is best if you sleep on your back or stomach.

Word of warning though – the GravityLux mattress does skew a little firm so manage your expectations.

Since the WinkBeds GravityLux is an all-foam mattress, it won’t be able to provide enough support for heavier-set sleepers the way a mattress that contains both foam and coils (hybrid) does.

We rate the WinkBeds GravityLux a 7 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The mattress skews slightly firm which is why I don’t give it full marks. But you still get comfort and pressure relief as long as you pick the firmness level that best suits your preferred sleeping position.

We rate the WinkBeds GravityLux a 10 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

You read that right. 10 out of 10 for a memory foam mattress that doesn’t contain any spring coils.

And it doesn’t even contain any fancy-schmancy cooling materials – just gel-infused memory foam and an open-celled proprietary foam the company calls Aircell. That’s enough that I felt it completely wick away heat while I slept.

We rate the WinkBeds GravityLux a 10 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

The multiple foam layers work together to absorb even the smallest movements. This is a great choice for couples.

We rate the WinkBeds GravityLux a 10 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

The mattress contains reinforced edges (which is pretty uncommon for all-foam mattresses) which helps give it extra edge support. This in turn allows you to sleep on more of the mattress surface.

Alternate pick: WinkBeds EcoCloud

Queen-size WinkBeds EcoCloud in the Sleepline Testing Studio
WinkBeds EcoCloud

If you prefer something with a coil unit, check out the WinkBeds EcoCloud mattress.

Made from a blend of certified organic Talalay latex and individually pocketed, recycled steel coils; the WinkBeds EcoCloud is a natural alternative to the GravityLux.


#6. Plank Firm Luxe

Plank Firm Luxe (queen)
Plank Firm Luxe

Pros

  • Suitable for heavier-set people
  • Cooling
  • Great edge support
  • Flippable design

Cons

  • Not suitable for side sleepers
  • Slight motion transfer

25% Off Coupon Code: SLEEPLINE25

Why it’s one of the best

The Plank Firm Luxe is by far the best ultra-firm mattress available in a queen-size that I’ve ever tried.

It’s also dual-sided (flippable) so you get more lifespan out it since you don’t have to worry about wearing out only one side.

While most flippable mattresses are usually all-foam, the Plank Firm Luxe features a spring coil support unit that can support overweight sleepers.

Both sides of the mattress are pretty firm though (I mean, it’s literally in the name) so if you’re a side sleeper, this won’t be the right fit for you.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 13 inches
Firmness levels Firm/Extra Firm
Materials Quilted cover, high density foam, supreme response comfort foam, individually wrapped steel Ascension coils
Free trial period 120 nights
Warranty length Lifetime warranty
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

Plank Firm Luxe Performance

The Plank Firm Luxe comes in two firmness levels – firm on one side and extra-firm on the other. Firmer mattresses are best for those who sleep only on their backs and stomachs.

We rate the Plank Firm Luxe an 8.5 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

When you think firm, you’re probably thinking ‘not comfortable’ – but only if you’re a side sleeper. Back and stomach sleepers get more than enough pressure point relief as well as comfort with either side of this mattress.

We rate the Plank Firm Luxe a 9 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

Although the mattress doesn’t contain any actively cooling materials, it still did a good job drawing heat away from the mattress. The firmness did a lot of the heavy lifting here – you’re basically laying on top of the bed as opposed to laying ‘within it’.

We rate the Plank Firm Luxe a 7 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

I did experience a very tiny amount of motion transfer when I tried it out with a partner but if you’re not a very light sleeper then this isn’t an issue.

We rate the Plank Firm Luxe a 10 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

Reinforced edge coils surround the perimeter of the entire mattress giving it superb edge support. This not only means that you can comfortably sleep close to or even on the edge of the bed but you have more of the mattress surface to roll around on – crucial especially if you share a bed.

25% Off Coupon Code: SLEEPLINE25

Alternate pick: Plank Firm

Queen Plank Firm mattress
Plank Firm Mattress

If you prefer something without springs, take a look at the base model Plank Firm.

Similar in construction to the Firm Luxe but without the coil unit, the bsae model Firm is also flippable and features two different firmness levels within one mattress – firm and extra-firm.

25% Off Coupon Code: SLEEPLINE25


#7. Birch Luxe Natural

Birch Luxe Natural queen size test
Birch Luxe Natural

Pros

  • Cooling and hypoallergenic
  • Made from natural latex
  • Offers responsive support
  • Great for back and stomach sleepers

Cons

  • May be a bit too firm for side sleepers
  • Not suitable for heavier-set sleepers

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

Why it’s one of the best

All-natural, organic and backed by numerous world-renowned certifications, the Birch Luxe Natural mattress performs consistently all across the board which is why it is one of our best queen-sized picks when it comes to organic mattresses.

Made from a blend of organic latex foam, organic wool, and recycled steel coils; the Birch Luxe Natural is hypoallergenic and cooling, making it ideal for those who suffer from seasonal allergies as well as those who sleep hot.

Unlike memory foam, which is contouring, latex foam like the one used in this mattress is more responsive which helps you achieve proper spinal alignment.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 11.5 inches
Firmness levels Medium Firm
Materials Euro top quilted cover, plant-based fire retardant, organic wool, natural latex foam, pocketed coils
Free trial period 100 nights
Warranty length Lifetime
Shipping Free
Certification GOLS, GOTS, Greenguard Gold

Birch Luxe Natural Performance

The Birch Luxe Natural sits at a 6.5 on the mattress firmness scale, giving it a medium-firm feel.

While this firmness level is good for all sleeper types including back and stomach sleepers, I find it to be a little too soft for heavier-set sleepers.

We rate the Birch Luxe Natural an 8 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The mattress provides zoned support which targets key areas of the body for extra support. I found that this was very effective.

We rate the Birch Luxe Natural a 9 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

As I’ve mentioned previously, pure organic latex like what’s used in this mattress is naturally cooling. That, coupled with organic wool (which is temperature-regulating) and the mattress’ coil unit makes the Birch Luxe Natural extremely cooling – perfect for hot sleepers.

We rate the Birch Luxe Natural an 8 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

While you might think that the combination of springy latex foam and a coil unit of considerable size is a recipe for disaster, I barely felt any motion transfer when I tried the mattress out with a partner.

We rate the Birch Luxe Natural an 8.5 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

The mattress features reinforced edge coils as well as thicker edge seams giving the mattress really good edge support. This allows you to sleep on the entire mattress surface.

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20

Alternate pick: Birch Natural

Base model Birch Natural
Birch Natural

If you want something slightly cheaper, check out the base model Birch Natural mattress.

Made with the same components as the Luxe Natural (but without the Euro pillow top and with less layers), the Birch Natural offers the similar responsive support.

It’s a great budget alternative, in my opinion.

20% off coupon code: SLEEPLINE20


#8. Glacier Original Hybrid

Glacier Original Hybrid
Glacier Original Hybrid

Pros

  • Offers responsive support
  • Cooling
  • Helps with proper spinal alignment
  • Good for back and stomach sleepers

Cons

  • Not good for side sleepers
  • Slight motion transfer

Why it’s one of the best

Cooling and affordable are the two main words that define why the Glacier Original Hybrid is on my best queen-size mattress list.

Each layer of the Glacier Original Hybrid contains active cooling tech such as graphite foam, cooling gel foam, and ventilated foam; so it should come as no surprise that it is very cooling (it’s also right there in the name).

The Glacier Original Hybrid’s slightly firmer mattress surface also helps you achieve proper spinal alignment, giving you much needed lumbar support. This is great if you’re a stomach sleeper.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 12 inches
Firmness levels Medium Firm
Materials Cooling Comfort cotton cover, graphite-infused memory foam, gel-infused memory foam, ARCFlow ventilated foam, pocketed steel coils, high density foam
Free trial period 365 nights
Warranty length Lifetime warranty
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

Glacier Original Hybrid Performance

The Glacier Original Hybrid sits on a 7.5 on the mattress firmness scale, giving it a medium-firm feel that slips more into the firmer end of the spectrum.

For that reason, I recommend the Glacier Original Hybrid to those who sleep mostly on their backs and stomachs. Strict side sleepers will find it to be too firm to provide them with the pressure relief they need.

We rate the Glacier Original Hybrid a 7.5 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

I would have rated this a little bit higher if it had been more of a medium firmness level. For back and stomach sleepers, the mattress provides ample pressure relief.

We rate the Glacier Original Hybrid an 8 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

There’s no question when it comes to cooling capabilities – every layer of the mattress contains some form of cooling tech that helps do away with heat retention, allowing you to sleep cool and fresh throughout the night.

We rate the Glacier Original Hybrid a 6 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

For a mattress that’s pretty firm (which usually helps with motion isolation), I still experienced a good amount of motion transfer when I it out with a partner. If you’re a light sleeper then I do not recommend it.

We rate the Glacier Original Hybrid a 7.5 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

Reinforced edge coils surround the perimeter of the entire mattress giving it extra edge support. Although not the best – I still experienced a tiny bit of sinkage when I laid right on top of the edge – it was not the worst either. You’ll be fine as long as you stay off the very edge.

Alternate pick: Glacier Summit Hybrid

Queen Glacier Summit Hybrid mattress
Glacier Summit Hybrid

If you’re a side sleeper and need something softer, check out the Glacier Summit Hybrid mattress.

Featuring the same cooling layers as the Original Hybrid, the Summit Hybrid comes in at a medium firmness level, making it suitable for all sleeper types.


#9. Puffy Royal

Queen Puffy Royal Hybrid
Puffy Royal Hybrid Mattress

Pros

  • Plush and luxurious
  • Cooling
  • Suitable for all sleeper types
  • Pressure relieving

Cons

Why it’s one of the best

I mean, who does not want to sleep on a bed that feels just as plush and luxurious as a 5-star hotel mattress?

I know I do and I know you do too.

The Puffy Royal features 10 (yes, TEN) layers which includes proprietary foam, specialty memory foam, and blended wool filling as well as a quilted cloud touch cover that feels just like a Euro Pillow top; giving you tons of compression and pressure point relief.

Another thing I liked a lot about the Puffy Royal is that even though it contains multiple layers of manmade foam, it still sleeps pretty cool which means even though it’s the type of bed that envelops you as you sleep, you won’t feel cocooned in your own body heat.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 14 inches
Firmness levels Medium
Materials Quilted cloud cover, blended wool filling, climate fiber layer, gel-infused cooling foam, memory foam, Cloud relief comfort foam, Cloud sculpting technology foam, foam-encased coils, Firm core support foam
Free trial period 101 nights
Warranty length Lifetime
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US

Puffy Royal Performance

The Puffy Royal mattress sits squarely on a 5 on the mattress firmness scale giving it a true medium feel.

This means it’s good for all sleeper types from side sleepers and combination sleepers to stomach and back sleepers.

Being a hybrid mattress, the Puffy Royal is good for heavier-set sleepers, although they might find the it to be more of a medium-soft rather than a true medium.

We rate the Puffy Royal a 9 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

With ten different layers there’s no doubt that the Puffy Royal offers comfort and pressure relief with just the right amount of compression. You won’t feel like you’re being swallowed up by the bed.

We rate the Puffy Royal an 8 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

The mattress features cooling gel-infused foam, blended wool, and Puffy’s own Climate Fiber layer that helps with temperature regulation. You’ll never feel too hot or too cold.

We rate the Puffy Royal a 9 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

The multiple foam layers absorb most, if not all, cross-mattress movement. I did not feel any motion transfer whatsoever when I tried it out with a partner, making it a good choice for those who share a bed.

We rate the Puffy Royal a 6.5 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

Even though the mattress contains reinforced edge coils, I found the edge support on the mattress to be pretty subpar, sadly. You WILL roll off the bed if lay close to the edge.


#10. Saatva Classic

Testing out a queen-sized Saatva Classic
Saatva Classic

Pros

  • Suitable for all sleeper types
  • Great for couples
  • Fiberglass-free
  • Responsive and pressure relieving

Cons

  • Edge support can be too firm
  • Can be too pricey for some

Why it’s one of the best

It’s not hard to see why the Saatva Classic deserves a spot on our best queen-size mattress roundup – with its chiropractor-approved combination of gel-infused premium memory foam, 14.5 gauge recycled steel coils, Euro pillow top, and Guardin-treated cover, the mattress is in a league of its own (and its price is in a league of its own too, in case you were wondering).

You get the benefits of both an innerspring mattress and a memory foam mattress with the Saatva Classic – compression and pressure relief as well as responsive support.

Saatva is also one of the very few mattress brands that treat all their mattresses with a botanical-based antimicrobial treatment which, in my honest opinion, adds a layer of safety to your overall sleep health.

Specs at a glance

Thickness levels 11.5 inches, 14.5 inches
Firmness levels Medium Soft, Medium, Medium Firm
Materials Organic cotton cover, Euro pillow top, gel-infused memory foam, 14.5 gauge recycled steel coils, high density foam rails, dual coil tempered steel
Free trial period 365 nights
Warranty length Lifetime
Shipping Free
Certification CertiPUR-US, Greenguard Gold

Saatva Classic Performance

You get to choose between three different firmness options – medium-soft, medium and medium-firm. 

The medium-soft version is best for strict side sleepers.

The medium version is good for all sleeper types.

The medium-firm version is best if you sleep on your back or stomach only.

The Saatva Classic also features a dual-coil design, which means it’s great for overweight sleepers.

We rate the Saatva Classic a 9.5 out of 10 when it comes to comfort and pressure relief.

The mattress is fully designed with comfort at the forefront so it should come as no surprise that it gets near perfect marks from us when it comes to comfort and pressure point relief. Like I said, you get the best bits of both an innerspring mattress and a memory foam mattress all in one.

We rate the Saatva Classic a 9.5 out of 10 when it comes to cooling.

For a mattress that does not really contain any actively cooling materials except for gel-infused memory foam, the Saatva Classic performs just as good – if not better – as other mattress brands that feature fancy cooling tech making it the perfect choice for those who sleep extremely hot.

We rate the Saatva Classic an 8.5 out of 10 when it comes to motion isolation.

Luckily I didn’t feel a lot of motion transfer when I tried the mattress out with a partner, so I can safely say that I recommend it for those who share a bed.

We rate the Saatva Classic a 7.5 out of 10 when it comes to edge support.

I’d say this was a case of “too much of a good thing can be a bad thing” – the reinforced edges are raised a little too high and are a little too firm. It can be a bit uncomfortable to lie on. On the upside, you do get to use the entire mattress surface.  


How we chose these mattresses

We picked these mattresses based on a complete list of factors that we believe make up a great queen-sized mattress. We base them all off the following criteria:

  • Pressure relief – Everyone has pressure points and this is important when it comes to choosing the right mattress. Depending on a person’s sleeping position, mattress firmness can greatly affect whether you would get enough pressure relief or not. We chose mattresses that offer maximum pressure relief.
  • Cooling – Sleeping hot is the number one cause of sleeplessness among the greater population and choosing mattresses that offer superb cooling capabilities is crucial to getting a good night’s sleep.
  • Firmness – Mattress firmness correlates to one’s preferred sleeping position and we chose mattresses that can suit most, if not all, sleeping positions from back sleeping to stomach sleeping and side sleeping.
  • Motion isolation – Picking a mattress that offers good motion isolation is important if you share a bed with a partner. We chose mattresses that are suitable for couples.
  • Edge support – Not only does edge support help (and protect!) those who prefer sleeping close to the edge of the bed, having a mattress with good edge support also provides you with a wider mattress surface.
  • Durability – We chose mattresses that we know would last long and ones that come with reasonable return policies.

Conclusion

What makes a good queen-sized mattress is what makes a good mattress, no matter the size. 

The mattresses on this list cover a wide range of preferences because a good mattress for one person may not be the best for another – there’s no one size fits all, especially when it comes to mattresses.

All the mattresses on this list have been chosen specifically for the factors we believe are important for every sleeper.


How we rate mattresses

We personally test and rate mattresses using the following strict quantitative criteria:

  1. Comfort
  2. Structural integrity and durability
  3. Firmness and support
  4. Cooling capabilities
  5. Pressure relief
  6. Edge support
  7. Motion isolation

Learn more about our mattress rating process and methodology here


Psst… the sleep review industry is full of liars, sharks, and thieves. It’s a modern-day version of getting ripped off at your local mattress store. So, why should you trust us?